My deck is still under construction. The builder is using trex transcend. It has long and short scratches all over it, and I actually was able to scratch it with my fingernail. There is a u-tube video where they were unable to scratch it with a key. I sat in a patio chair with plastic leg protectors and scootched as one would leaving a table and it gouged the surface! Supplier came out to look, took pictures, and thinks it is a bad batch. Trex rep hasn't seen it yet but will. The plan is that the big box store will replace the Transcend with the same or different product at no expense. It's a huge and expensive deck. I love the look and feel of Transcend, and if I knew this was really not typical of the product, I'd pick it again. However I do have real reservations about making the same mistake twice. I have to admit, I have little faith in the word of a biased company. The word of those who use and install carries far more weight. The builder, right in front of me slid some very lightweight aluminum across and it dug scratches in. I looked at Ipe to substitute, but it is more than double the cost and I'd like to stick with composites Menards sells. The alternatives are lower priced trex lines or the Menards product. Is my description of the ease of scratching typical for REAL use of Transcend? I already know what the promotional materials say...