DIY Home Improvement Forum banner

Door Sweep VS Door Seal

6.6K views 3 replies 2 participants last post by  chandler48  
#1 ·
It was suggested to me by someone that for my old inswing door, I should replace the threshold (I used a commercial aluminum one) and use a door sweep on the inside instead of a door seal that goes between bottom of door and seal. I was told that the seals that attach to the bottoms of doors don’t hold up and aren’t very good.

I was wondering if there is a concensus regarding which is better, a door sweep or seal? Or should they be used in conjunction? I did just the neoprene door sweep for one of my doors and it seems to let lots do dust onto the threshold up to the sweep. The door in the photo has a stainless kick I plate I installed, and a gap on the bottom since there is no bottom seal. On the inside it has a neoprene door sweep installed against the threshold.

I have one more door to do and debating the course to take.

637698


637702
 
#2 ·
This is a commercial application, so what we say here may not apply. Using a door seal without an extension cord tearing it up would be ideal, but as a fail safe, the door sweep, as indicated in the second picture could help stop cold drafts as it should touch the threshold when the door closes. It should not scrape the floor material at all.
 
#3 ·
Thanks Chandler48. The extension cord is from when I was using heat lamps to set epoxy on the 304 stainless bottom kick plate. I did that because the bottom veneer was deteriorated too much to save, and could not find a new one of appropriate thickness.

The other non commercial exterior door, next to the one in the photo, will be getting a similar kick plate and will need either a seal, sweep, or both. If I do a seal I will need to cut the bottom of the door to gain clearance.

So you prefer the seal over the sweep. Any any particular reason why?
 
#4 ·
The seals have several layers of "fingers" that roll across your threshold insert helping to create an air prevention area. Depending on the type of threshold you have, it could be adjustable via screws in 4 or 5 places. This helps to tweak the seal without making the door difficult to open or close. The sweep will work in conjunction to the seal as an added buffer so to speak. If your door fits the opening now without a seal, try a sweep to keep from cutting the door off.