DIY Home Improvement Forum banner

1 - 20 of 40 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
6 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
:wallbash:

Please help… this sounds crazy by my ac thermostat changes by itself !! here is what happens:

Last summer I noticed that my ac been running for a long time so when I go check the setting I found out that my set temp was too low (sometime is 60 or 55.. random) even though I’ve set the temp to let’s say 80. At first I though that my kids been messing with the settings but when I started paying attention and setting the temp when the whole family is not home I found out that the thermostat setting is ACTUALLY changing by itself.

When the problem continued this year.. I said that’s it I will replace the thermostat so I did and bought a new thermostat (programmable & different brand than the one I had) but the problem still there.

I have to mention that my original/old thermostat was NOT programmable. Also, I have 2 ac units for my 2 story home and the problem is happening only on 1 of them.

After I replaced the old thermostats with new one I even tried to swap the thermostats but the problem didn’t follow the thermostat but stayed with the downstairs unit.

I brought a friend AC technician and he checked the wiring and voltages and everything tested OK and he actually told me that he never heard of this problem… and its impossible that it could happen..

I need help…
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
39,464 Posts
Wife or kids.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6 Posts
Discussion Starter #4
No guys its not the wife or kids.. I mentioned in the post that I watched happen when I am alone in the house too many times now...
 

·
I'm Your Huckleberry
Joined
·
5,884 Posts
I've heard of static electricity (socks on carpet through fingers) messing up digital stats so would anyone think this could may be touching on what is going on?

Just wondering.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6 Posts
Discussion Starter #7
Doc Holliday: is it possable also that I am getting some feedback current or voltage from the transformer (or whatever supplying the voltage to the thermostat)? that's causing the setting to change?

hvactech126:The original thermostat was a NON-PROGRAMMBLE one that the problem started with ... then is doing the same thing with a programmable one. clearly, its not the thermostat
 

·
AKA HVACTECHFW
Joined
·
2,426 Posts
clearly as an experienced professional I have no idea what I'm talking about.... A thermostat can not be changed by anything other than the end user. the thermostat is no more than a switch. It connects wires to send the proper signal for the system to perform said function.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,031 Posts
A short circuit in the thermostat circuit causing the air conditioning to be on continuously and the lowest temperature the system can achieve is 65 degrees?
 

·
I'm Your Huckleberry
Joined
·
5,884 Posts
Doc Holliday: is it possable also that I am getting some feedback current or voltage from the transformer (or whatever supplying the voltage to the thermostat)? that's causing the setting to change?
Any thing is possible at this point as judging from all of these techs who know much more than myself about things of this nature, a stat just dropping set point on it's own is out of the ordinary. You said you changed the stat from the other system in your home and it did the same thing so I would have to believe that yes, something in the circuitry elsehwere in the one system is causing your stat to drop. Not sure how exactly, that feat is not something that is supposed to be possible.

I'm wondering if by chance you have a resistor of some sort on the control board in your furnace causing some sort of distortion. This is all guess work from me as I honestly have no clue if a resistor could do that.

Is the stat that you borrowed from the other system back on the original system you took it from? If not, I'd try putting it back and see how it acts after it's been on the problem system.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6 Posts
Discussion Starter #11
hvactech126: I know what's happening it doesn't make sense not only to you but to me too ... BUT IT'S Happening .. that's why I am posting here to seek an advice from professinoals like yourself, I have ZERO expereince with HVAC but I am an engineer where I've worked with diffrent electronics products and seen some wiered stuff that a noise or feedback currents mess some circuits AND ONLY when you find the real cause, you say WOW .... BUT before that everything doesn't make sense...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6 Posts
Discussion Starter #12
hvactech126: i'll swap the stats tomorrow gain & see if the problem stays with location or follows the stat & will post, I did this test last week & the problem stayed with location.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6 Posts
Discussion Starter #13
BTW: Thanks to evryone here trying to help with thier thoughts, I TRULY APPRICATE IT. Thank you guys.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4 Posts
Just Happened To Me

Has there been any explanation on this yet? This just happened to me.

We have a generic Honeywell thermostadt in our bedroom to control the space heater on the floor. I was in the bedroom taking a nap before work and my girlfriend was on the computer. I had the window open and the fan on because it's pretty warm out right now, and we don't have AC in our apartment.

Well, I got woken up by out bedroom door slamming from the breeze outside and my gf comes in to prop the door open for me so it doesn't happen again. Well, before I could get to sleep, I smell something burning. I call out to her asking if she forgot something on the stove because the smell was getting stronger. She says no and comes in to investigate. She claims the smell is coming from our bedroom, and begins unplugging the fan, thinking that the small motor was overheating or something. When she got down to unplug it, she realizes the smell got stronger, and that it's actually coming from the heat register by the floor. She goes to the door to check out the thermostadt and it's been turned all the way to the right! It's been sitting all the way to the left since it started getting warm after winter! There's no need to have it on!

This is an generic-style thermostadt I'm talking about here. The small, white, Honeywell with the big dial on it. It's not programmable or anything like that. And, we had just bought it last winter, and the dial is pretty firm, not loose or anything. You have to make a conscious effort to change it from off to on, just to be sure everyone understands it couldn't have happened when we went to flip the switch or anything.

The only explanation I can think of is if, perhaps, there is some sort of coil behind the dial with potential to turn the dial when the wall was jostled by the slamming door. I have no other explanation for it.

Does anyone have any other idea how this could happen? Anything other than "it's a ghost"? It's really bothering me because I don't believe in ghosts, lol and I'm not too fond with arguments from ignorance. There's got to be some logical way for this to happen.

And I promise, it wasn't my girlfriend. I already drilled her about it and there's no way she touched it, nor did I sleepwalk to turn it on.

Any info on this would be great since I can't find any other site talking about this. Every search takes you to thermostadts that change because they are programmable. But, nothing like this.

Thanks!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
837 Posts
borrow a video camera and set it up.... thermostats normally don't change themselves.... something fishy going on......:eek::eek::eek::eek:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4 Posts
borrow a video camera and set it up.... thermostats normally don't change themselves.... something fishy going on......:eek::eek::eek::eek:
We've lived there for two years and this is the first instance of something like this happening. Is there no mechanism in the thermostadt that could allow for it to move on its own if the conditions are right?
 

·
Wire Chewer
Joined
·
3,579 Posts
I'm not of much help, but I thought I'd share a funny thermostat story I heard at work.(phone company)

One time they got a trouble ticket, the customer said every time someone called them, their furnace would start. The tech was like "whaaaa?!" So he goes over to check it out. Someone had hooked up the thermostat wire to the phone line somehow. LOL

Maybe your thermostat is hooked up to something it should not? lol
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4 Posts
I'm not of much help, but I thought I'd share a funny thermostat story I heard at work.(phone company)

One time they got a trouble ticket, the customer said every time someone called them, their furnace would start. The tech was like "whaaaa?!" So he goes over to check it out. Someone had hooked up the thermostat wire to the phone line somehow. LOL

Maybe your thermostat is hooked up to something it should not? lol
lol. No, no, it's an Honeywell, non-programmable, analog model. The connection is quite simple. Im just wondering of the coil inside could somehow "buckle" from the heat, or somehow exert some force on the dial?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4 Posts
Trying to go about this logically has only brought me to one other conclusion. I'm assuming the thermostat has been on cranked for quite some time, and we just hadn't noticed since its been so hot in the apartment that it just didn't trigger the heat register (as it would give the distinct smell of turning on that we just haven't experienced until today).

Being that today was much cooler, when the breeze came through and slammed the door, it displaced the air enough to trigger the thermostat to turn on, giving the effect that someone had turned it on today without anyone being around.

However, the problem still exists knowing that nobody has come to visit that would have played with the thermostat, and that neither me or my girlfriend have touched it since turning them off after the winter months.

Although this sounds more logical, it still doesn't make any sense...
 

·
HVAC Contractor
Joined
·
422 Posts
Mechanical thermostats can get out or whack at times and need to be recalibrated, but generally those recalibrations are just a few degrees - not nearly enough to significantly alter the settings. Could have simply been that, or someone could have inadvertantly bumped it up while cleaning, walking beside it, carrying something in the room, etc etc. I can beleive a digital tstat could do what is described earlier in this thread - turn on by itself, or move settings up/down - but a mechanical thermostat requires physical movement to alter settings.
 
1 - 20 of 40 Posts
Top