DIY Home Improvement Forum banner

Siding stain gone bad?

445 Views 4 Replies 2 Participants Last post by  Photobug
I did not seal up a gallon of the stain I bought last year. Over the top of the stain was a large rubbery layer. I mixed it up and used it to stain a few small pieces to finish trimming out a window.

The rubbery pieces just broke up and are still in the can as large pieces. The stain appears more solid (richer darker color) less transparent on the wood. A day after I stained the cedar it rained and the stained wood appears to shed water very well.

The stain is Cabot's semi-solid stain in evergreen color. My previous source no longer carries it but it is available at my Ace hardware. I don't mind the darker color but don't want to waste time staining something that may not last as long as a freshly bought stain.

Can I trust this stain or should I buy a new can?
1 - 5 of 5 Posts
How thick was the dried paint [rubbery stuff] on top?
How thick was the dried paint [rubbery stuff] on top?
Seemed pretty thick 3/4-1" on top of a full gallon. Mixed it they have stayed big chunks floating in the stain.
I usually cut the skin off of the top and toss it. That is pretty thick for a skin, hard to say if the stain is still good [probably ok] It's best to strain old paint so the buggers don't end up in the finish.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
I usually cut the skin off of the top and toss it. That is pretty thick for a skin, hard to say if the stain is still good [probably ok] It's best to strain old paint so the buggers don't end up in the finish.
Thanks for the info. I just ordered another gallon from Ace. I can strain the old one and mix the two together to get a color consistency and get whatever solids that will be strained out from the old batch to be supplemented from the new batch.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
1 - 5 of 5 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top