DIY Home Improvement Forum banner

Shower won't shut off!

10124 Views 3 Replies 4 Participants Last post by  oh'mike
So hubby and I are replacing what was a tiny neo angle shower with a tub sized shower at our cabin (which is a 4 hr drive away... this is important). We gutted the old shower, purchased a basic Delta valve/faucet and proceeded to re-plumb! With the new rough in in place, we tiled over the plumbing, proceeded to install the balance of the new plumbing (cartridge, bonnet, etc). In the process of installing this I was fiddling with the cartridge to change the hot water limit stop location, and promptly dropped it on the tile floor! Needless to say the cartridge blew apart, springs and rubber washers flying everywhere! Fine... laugh!

I consulted the internet on how to put the pieces back together (after a big freak out by the hubby!). I'm fairly certain I put all the pieces back where they belonged, but after we installed the cartridge, handle, etc, and turned on the shower, it ran ok... but the water wouldn't shut off! Not even a little... NOT AT ALL!

Needless to say we pulled the cartridge out, turned the water off at the shut off set screws. Now that I'm back in town I sheepishly made a trip to the plumbing wholesaler and purchased a new cartridge. Hoping to get back next weekend and try my luck as a plumber again.

But until then........ my question to the plumbers here is... Is it the cartridge that is the problem? Or could there be some underlying other issue, like could something have gone REALLY WRONG in the rough in that will only be able to be fixed if we pull all the tile off the wall and start over??

Any/all advice is more than welcome. Thanks!
1 - 1 of 4 Posts
Kind of confused but if the only thing between the water supply and the shower head is the valve and cartridge doesn't it have to be a flaw there? Or are you saying it is leaking water between the shower valve and the cutoffs?

I am guessing the replacement cartridge will fix this. Those things tend to crack in strange and mysterious places when dropped. I would never have taken the time to even try to rebuild one. And I am not a plumber! I just pay them handsomely and have put many of their kids through school over the years.

I just cannot stand the arrogant souls storming into my home (I don't mind them in those of my clients) lecturing me about faucet repairs I attempted myself and managed to "f" up. And of course I don't even have to pay them--much--for work on my place.
1 - 1 of 4 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.