DIY Home Improvement Forum banner
1 - 3 of 3 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
4 Posts
Hey guys, I want to check if it's time for my windows to be replaced. They are quite old and have become crackly and makes noises. Also I recently tested if they have become drafty based on an article in a window review site. And it seems like they are.
So since I am gonna replace them I am thinking of getting energy efficient windows. Are they any good? Any experiences?
 

· Registered
Joined
·
14,947 Posts
There have been many articles related to just how much new windows will save on energy costs and NONE have concluded they are big savers. Payback is usually out in the 20 year range and with today's lower energy costs it may be longer now.

Having said that I have replaced most (eventually all) of my old double pane double hung windows as part of my insulation upgrade including new siding. The timing was right and the wife was tired of having ugly hard to open windows. I'll never save enough from just the windows, but they are an excellent upgrade given the effort involved with all of the other improvements.

Sometimes you just want new and every time I open one of our new windows with one finger I'm happy.

If you have old single pane windows you will benefit more. But that article is misleading. If you add up all of the air leaks in a typical home there is a 12" x 12" in the side of your home. Of that, windows contribute very little and, and, you need all of those leaks to maintain air quality. Recommended minimum air exchange is 1/3 of all inside air every hour. Tighter than that and you develop moisture issues and low quality air.

The explanation gets longer but consider your window upgrade for reasons other than saving energy. I like mine and I'm an energy auditor (retired).

Bud
 

· Banned
Joined
·
30,077 Posts
Bud,

Agree with you on 90% except the part about air leakage. I do agree that if you play the averages, there are a bunch more place for air leakage. I will say this with regards to air leakage at windows though. More than a handful that we see won't even close any longer (more so new construction units from the early 90's) and those are big sources of air and energy losses.

Either way, you are 100% correct that there are a myriad of reasons beyond just energy to replace your windows...or not replace your windows for that matter.
 
1 - 3 of 3 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top