DIY Home Improvement Forum banner
1 - 6 of 6 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
223 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 · (Edited)
I have a FHP A/C that is only about 8 years old. I bought the house 14 years ago and replaced the old FHP after about 6 years. I would guess that one lasted 14 years.

It pulls ground water in FL and dumps it into the canal. It is on a stand in the garage. I had AC guys come in to quote last time and they groaned about a new AC because there is no existing set up for the condensor outside. There is power and concrete. I decided to put in another FHP.

I am thinking conventional AC again. Lots of deals on Rheems and Goodmans. If you had to choose? Rheem?

I have a smaller back up that is a Trane that is working but it only can cool half of the house and it is kept as a back up.

Any suggestions on heat pump ACs? Bosch AG bought FHP. So I guess they may have better German engineering but they are pricey.

All these heat pumps seem pricey. Any suggestions? Thanks.
 

·
HVAC Contractor
Joined
·
422 Posts
Best heat pump on the market IMO is a Trane, followed by higher end Carriers.

I personally wouldn't install a Goodman hp (had too much trouble with them) but others may have different experiences. In FL, you won't have much need for heating of course, but still - when you need it, you want it to work.

I've had too many leak issues with Rheem/Ruud to recommend them. They work well enough, but we installed quite a few of them a few years back, and saw an inordinate amount of leaks in both evap and condenser coils.

This is just my own personal opinion, of course, and others will have different experiences.
 

·
Administrator
Joined
·
41,640 Posts
Get quotes/prices on other brands of water source heat pumps/air conditioners.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
272 Posts
personally I would not buy either. Both are OK but there is better in my opinion for the same money. If I had to choose between them I would pick Goodman. I have installed both and these are just my opinion. I use Payne for my low cost installs. Payne is a carrier on a buget
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
223 Posts
Discussion Starter · #6 ·
Best heat pump on the market IMO is a Trane, followed by higher end Carriers.

I personally wouldn't install a Goodman hp (had too much trouble with them) but others may have different experiences. In FL, you won't have much need for heating of course, but still - when you need it, you want it to work.

I've had too many leak issues with Rheem/Ruud to recommend them. They work well enough, but we installed quite a few of them a few years back, and saw an inordinate amount of leaks in both evap and condenser coils.

This is just my own personal opinion, of course, and others will have different experiences.
Thanks guys and possibly gals. I have Tranes at my office and one smaller back up at the house for Florida room. This little one is tiding me over for now. A relative has a 10 year old Trane and it is ice cold like new. Great A/Cs.

I am staying with heat pump and the choices from my tech company are probably Carrier and Liquid Furnace. I am replacing Florida Heat Pump which Bosch now owns. FHP is a great heat punp/AC but compressors seem to fail like clockwork at 5 years. :mad:
 
1 - 6 of 6 Posts
Top