DIY Home Improvement Forum banner
1 - 18 of 18 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
764 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I am replacing the three original toilet water supply lines and bibs that were installed when my house was new 22 years ago. It would be an easy job but for the brass cokmpression ferrule that does not want to come off of the 1/2" copper tubing coming out of the wall.

I knew it would be tough so I bought a puller at Home Depot ahead of time. It is desighed for that very task, but it wouldn't work. http://www.homedepot.com/buy/brassc...e-and-compression-sleeve-puller-kit-t168.html

For now, I simply used the old bib's end cap (whatever you call the piece on the wall side of the water valve, which screws onto the bib housing to compress the brass ferrule), but would like to get it off and use the new parts. Also I have two more to go.

There isn't enough room to slide the bib's end cap back towards the wall so that I can cut the brass ferrule off with my dremel else I may do that.

Any suggestions? Thanks.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
764 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 · (Edited)
gregzoll, The guys at HD showed me the shark bite, which is good knowledge if you have no other option, but I don't want to use one. Before doing so I will go with the old compression fitting.

The tip of the copper tubing protrudes about 1" from the drywall. I can't tell for sure, since I have the new water valve fit on for now and the toilet hooked up, but I may possibly be able to get access to the brass compresson fitting bu cutting the round chromed wall flange away. If I have to, I can enlarge the hole in the drywall just enough to push the old water valve cap back into the wall and get access to the brass compression ferrel.

I just bought this Multi Tool and used it to cut some brass toilet hold down bolts. It went throough them like butter. I suppose I could use that to cut most of the way through the brass ferrel and then insert a screwdriver into the slot to break the compression fitting open.

This picture should help clarify things.

Then I should be able to pop on a new wall flange, followed by the new valves end cap, followed by the new brass compression fitting and etcetera.

I even have a new Wall Flange, as well as some of that awful paint if needed, but any drywall repairs should be hidden by the chrome flange. That reminds me, the guys at HD suggested that I could put the shark bit inside the wall but I don't like the idea and doubt that it is code.

Does this make sense?
 

Attachments

·
Retired Moderator
Joined
·
25,770 Posts
Why not replace only the valve and reuse the old nut and ferrule?

Use a Brass Craft brand 1/4 turn ball valve----

The old ferrule often leaves a dimple in the copper pipe----rendering that bit of pipe unsuited to accept a new ferrule--
 

·
Doing it myself
Joined
·
3,838 Posts
Most times it's not worth pulling the old ferrule off. If it's that tight, the connection between the ferrule and the pipe is very tight. All you have to do is get the valve to seal against the ferrule. If you're having trouble, clean the brass ferrule up a bit with some emery cloth and try a dab of pipe dope around the mating surfaces.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
764 Posts
Discussion Starter · #8 ·
Why not replace only the valve and reuse the old nut and ferrule?

Use a Brass Craft brand 1/4 turn ball valve----

The old ferrule often leaves a dimple in the copper pipe----rendering that bit of pipe unsuited to accept a new ferrule--

That is what I did, except it's a Brass Craft multi turn angle valve. What you said about the dimple being left in the old pipe brings up a concern I had, which was if the old sleeve was so tight a crease may be left in the pipe that would prevent a good seal, and if that is the case, the pipe would not extend far enough from the wall if I cut the bad piece away.

Anyhow, I did like you suggest and used the old nut and ferrule. Not a drop leaked in 18 hours. (The picture I posted was taken of the old nut and new valve with new supply line.) Thanks again Mike.

BTW, that multi tool is great for cutting brass valve stems to lenth as well as brass toilet hold down bolts that are a PITA if you have to saw them off in a tight area with a hacksaw.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
764 Posts
Discussion Starter · #9 ·
Most times it's not worth pulling the old ferrule off. If it's that tight, the connection between the ferrule and the pipe is very tight. All you have to do is get the valve to seal against the ferrule. If you're having trouble, clean the brass ferrule up a bit with some emery cloth and try a dab of pipe dope around the mating surfaces.
That worked great!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
764 Posts
Discussion Starter · #10 ·
I may pick one of those up. So far leaving the old nut and ferrule works, but this would be good to have if I run into one that doesn't want to seal and I have to get the sleeve off.

I remember having the same problem with a water valve for the Refrigerator ice make, and that was when the house was only 13 years old. I had to cut the ferrule off, which always runs the risk of damaging the copper tubing. If possible to get the old ferrule off, that is what I prefer.
 

·
Building tradesman
Joined
·
37 Posts
option

You can always very lightly spread a thin thin layer of a teflon pipe sealing paste around the existing ferrule getting some in to the wall side between the nut and the ferrule which will lubricate and allow for the joint to be tightened easier without binding and stressing the connection as well as filling any slight imperfections.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
764 Posts
Discussion Starter · #12 ·
You can always very lightly spread a thin thin layer of a teflon pipe sealing paste around the existing ferrule getting some in to the wall side between the nut and the ferrule which will lubricate and allow for the joint to be tightened easier without binding and stressing the connection as well as filling any slight imperfections.
That is a good idea. Those old original construction water lines are crap. Sure enough, I carefully moved one out of the way under the kitchen sink in order to do a minor repair, but the cold water line sprung a leak where the line is soldered to the water bib. Fortuanately I had a spare as I am going from room to rook upgrading things.

Meanwhile, the local plumbing supply has one of the pullers jaydevires mentioned and it is in stocdk for $30. I plan on picking one up and pulling all the old ferrules unless they just do not want to come off and there is insufficient space to cut the pipe.
 

·
Retired Moderator
Joined
·
25,770 Posts
You may be disappointed---if that puller does remove the ferrule---the pipe will(may) be dimpled and will not accept a new one---the compression of the nut presses the ferrule into the pipe,
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
764 Posts
Discussion Starter · #15 ·
You may be disappointed---if that puller does remove the ferrule---the pipe will(may) be dimpled and will not accept a new one---the compression of the nut presses the ferrule into the pipe,
So if the ferrule doesn't come off with a reasonable amount of pressure, cut it off and cut just behind where the pipe is dimpled. But, if there isn't enough pipe to play with, leave the original.
 

·
Doing it myself
Joined
·
3,838 Posts
I'm wondering how many times you will need to state that to get people to believe it.:laughing: That's what makes it seal.
Stick around for a while. You'll find that as many people that join each day to ask a single question, at least 100% of them don't listen to advice, and just do whatever they want to anyway, even though they asked for advice, simply because they didn't get the answer they wanted to hear.


:jester::jester::jester:
 
1 - 18 of 18 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top