DIY Home Improvement Forum banner
1 - 11 of 11 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
13 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I sent in a sample of my popcorn ceiling to Pro-Lab for asbestos testing. It came back as positive, with 5% Chrysotile, 40% Styrofoam and 55% binders. My question is, can I still remove the popcorn ceiling safely, or is this a job I should hire to an abatement company for? Do they make air quality gauges you can buy or rent if you do the project yourself?

Thank you.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
290 Posts
That is a job that is best left to professionals. There are no DIY ways to know that the contamination is not being spread around during removal. An abatement company will seal off the room with plastic sheeting, wet down and remove the popcorn, then clean up thoroughly, before bringing in an independent testing company--possibly even the one that tested your sample--when the test is clear, the plastic sheeting is removed and disposed of, then the room is ready to use again.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
11,194 Posts
While overlaying works, the hazard is still there. You would still encounter it the next time you disturb the ceiling.

I would have it abated so the hazard is removed.

If you overlay the asbestos, most areas require that you disclose it when you sell or rent the place.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
3,612 Posts
If you overlay the asbestos, most areas require that you disclose it when you sell or rent the place.
Most areas also require that you disclose that asbestos had been found previously on the property even if it has been abated. The problem the OP made was having the popcorn tested. If he had just removed it carefully nothing would have been known nor any problems created.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,568 Posts
Except per chance if someone found out. The odds of that at pretty small but none the less around here, disposing of asbestos in anything other than with a certified asbestos waste handler is punishable by fines significantly higher than the asbestos abatement would cost. And the OP can rest easier that his family won't be inhaling asbestos fiber.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
13 Posts
Discussion Starter · #7 ·
Except per chance if someone found out. The odds of that at pretty small but none the less around here, disposing of asbestos in anything other than with a certified asbestos waste handler is punishable by fines significantly higher than the asbestos abatement would cost. And the OP can rest easier that his family won't be inhaling asbestos fiber.
This about sums up my feelings on the matter. I don't want to have it in the house, and I'm willing to pay to have it removed. But I'm concerned that having a "professional" do it will actually mean they won't be as careful as I would and remnants will remain in the house.
 

· Low Slope Roofing
Joined
·
1,451 Posts
Around here a homeowner can remove all the asbestos they want, and just toss it in the regular trash.

As a business you have to be certified, follow all the PPE guidelines, Double bag it, take it to the dumb at a certain time on a certain day. It is suppose to be hand unloaded but every time I've went the dozer operator just said dump the truck in the hole over there, then does a couple of cookies over the bags breaking them open and covers them in dirt.

But I do one thing wrong I get fined, sued, or both.

@OP, with asbestos it isn't like you inhale one fiber and it's a death sentence. The people that have gotten sick from it, from the most part worked years in factories where the dust was all around. There is a lot of misconceptions about asbestos, you won't get sick from it being in building products. It can only harm when it is breathed in.

If it were me, and since the laws in my area allow it I would remove it my self. I would segregate the room from the rest of the house, including the HVAC system in that room. Wet the ceiling down with water, until it could be easily scraped off the ceiling, bag it and toss it how ever they require you to do it. When I was doing the work I would be in a respirator, and tyvek suit and would have a hepa air filter running the whole time, a big one.

Now if one does not feel comfortable doing it them self, then they should hire it out. It's not a difficult process, and if proper gear is warn it's not any more dangerous then breathing the air, it's just a PITA and that's why it's so expensive, as a business the training, equipment ect and the general hassle is a lot. Also you local regulations may not allow a homeowner to remove it.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,994 Posts
Around here a homeowner can remove all the asbestos they want, and just toss it in the regular trash.

As a business you have to be certified, follow all the PPE guidelines, Double bag it, take it to the dumb at a certain time on a certain day. It is suppose to be hand unloaded but every time I've went the dozer operator just said dump the truck in the hole over there, then does a couple of cookies over the bags breaking them open and covers them in dirt.

But I do one thing wrong I get fined, sued, or both.

@OP, with asbestos it isn't like you inhale one fiber and it's a death sentence. The people that have gotten sick from it, from the most part worked years in factories where the dust was all around. There is a lot of misconceptions about asbestos, you won't get sick from it being in building products. It can only harm when it is breathed in.

If it were me, and since the laws in my area allow it I would remove it my self. I would segregate the room from the rest of the house, including the HVAC system in that room. Wet the ceiling down with water, until it could be easily scraped off the ceiling, bag it and toss it how ever they require you to do it. When I was doing the work I would be in a respirator, and tyvek suit and would have a hepa air filter running the whole time, a big one.

Now if one does not feel comfortable doing it them self, then they should hire it out. It's not a difficult process, and if proper gear is warn it's not any more dangerous then breathing the air, it's just a PITA and that's why it's so expensive, as a business the training, equipment ect and the general hassle is a lot. Also you local regulations may not allow a homeowner to remove it.
another articulate response from 1985... :vs_karate:

and a reminder he has an outstanding balance of $15 for previous raving reviews :vs_cool:
 

· Registered
Joined
·
5,850 Posts
If it was me..

http://www.homedepot.com/p/QEP-14-in-Wide-Floor-Surface-Scraper-20900Q/100147899




http://www.homedepot.com/s/tyvek%2520suit?NCNI-5



http://www.homedepot.com/p/Sundstro...-SearchPLPHorizontal1_rr-_-NA-_-202714636-_-N




Also, purchase some clear plastic sheets from the dollar store.
Cover the walls and close off other areas using plastic.
Use same plastic for drop cloths.
Wet the popcorn down and scrape off.
Bag all trash using 3 mil contractor bags.
Haul to a dump near you.

If not, don't sweat it, it will only cost about $1400 to have someone do it for you....
 
1 - 11 of 11 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top