Did a lot of research before I had my root replaced to find the best roofing contractor in my area. They recommended the Atlas Pinnacle Pristine but said that the GAF Timberlines were about the same. We went with the Atlas because of the copper. We have one section of roof where we have had algae issues because it never gets sun. They look nice but have only been there for a couple months. Looked at some other houses and commercial buildings where they used the Atlas shingles and they still look good after a few years.
Since those are the upper line shingles from the manufacturers, I would think that they would all be pretty close to the same. Not familiar with Tamko. What is probably most important is the quality of the installation. Could be the best shingles ever, but if poorly installed, you will have issues down the road. Check out the roofer carefully.
Since those are the upper line shingles from the manufacturers, I would think that they would all be pretty close to the same. Not familiar with Tamko. What is probably most important is the quality of the installation. Could be the best shingles ever, but if poorly installed, you will have issues down the road. Check out the roofer carefully.