DIY Home Improvement Forum banner

1 - 20 of 20 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
9 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
......I am hoping that someone can help. I had the brilliant idea of changing all of my outlets and light switches in my living room and have somehow created a mess. First, I replaced all the outlets and everything worked fine, then I started on the light switches. At the hallway entering the living room I have switches there that controls dimming ceiling lights, overhead living room lights, and the bottom of EVERY outlet in the living room. In the living room I have four outlets that control 1) The bottom of every outlet as well 2) The Overhead living room lights as well 3) A ceiling fan 4) The outside light. Round one, ceiling fan (which I did not touch) dimming lights (which I did not touch) and outside lights (which I did replace) worked. The one that controls the bottom outlets and the overhead lights did not work. I googled it and read that I needed to break the tab on the outlets which could be a possible cause to what was going on. So, I went back, broke all the tabs and tried again. This solved the problem of the outlet switch so everything is working properly except my overhead lights. They will not come on at all. Now, of the two overhead light switches that I had, I only replaced one of them (the other I never touched!). I was VERY careful not to mix up the whole three wires but now nothing works. Yes, I say three because for some reason that one is not grounded (I am still using the switch that contains the four screws)........ it wasn't before and still isn’t. Well, when it did not work, I put on the old switch and yet it still will not work. I thought maybe I did mix up those three wires so I tried it a different way but still nothing...... (those wires are red, black, and white if that is relevant). Now I don't know….. All I do know is that my hubby is none pleased with my brilliant adventure and that I now have seriously messed it up. Any help/insight you could provide me would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!
 

·
I=E/R
Joined
·
2,052 Posts
When you broke the tab on the outlets, did you only break the bronze colored one or did you do both the bronze and silver?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9 Posts
Discussion Starter #3
I only broke the right side (bronze colored) one. On the previous ones I uninstalled only the right side was broke......
 

·
You talking to me?
Joined
·
7,551 Posts
are the lights that aren't working switched from only one switch or are there more than one switch that operate those lights?
 

·
I=E/R
Joined
·
2,052 Posts
I only broke the right side (bronze colored) one. On the previous ones I uninstalled only the right side was broke......
Good - that is correct.
You say you have a switch with four wires. Is one a bare copper wire going to a green screw or do all four wires have insulation?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9 Posts
Discussion Starter #6
The lights that are not working are operated by two different switches (one of them I changed) and the other I did not touch.... once it wouldn't work I tried to put the old switch back on, but it still does not work.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9 Posts
Discussion Starter #7
The one switch that I did not touch has four wires (one is the bare copper grounding wire). The one that I messed with only has three wires (missing the grounding wire).
 

·
You talking to me?
Joined
·
7,551 Posts
if they operate from 2 locations, you need to use a 3-way switch at each of those locations. Do you have a couple 3 way switches? They will have 3 terminal screws plus (probably) one for the ground wire (which should be green).


do you have any way to check for voltage on a wire? Makes it a lot easier.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
598 Posts
The new switch,is it a "Three Way switch" Hence- Two Brass screw and a black one? The old switch is it like what I described above?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9 Posts
Discussion Starter #10
if they operate from 2 locations, you need to use a 3-way switch at each of those locations. Do you have a couple 3 way switches? They will have 3 terminal screws plus (probably) one for the ground wire (which should be green).


do you have any way to check for voltage on a wire? Makes it a lot easier.

Yes, I have those switches.... I got the new ones from Lowes (after I took one of the old ones in) and specifically asked for help. When it didn't work, I doubted them and ended up going back to the old ones (which did work before I messed with it!!). I have no way to check for voltage on a wire, I do not even know what that means!! :no:
 

·
Wire Chewer
Joined
·
3,579 Posts
3 ways... I always find them tricky to work with. Sometimes the screws on the switch won't correspond with the ones on the old switch.

you can always use crocodile clips to setup a simple circuit using batteries so you can find which screw does what, then try to reproduce the same thing with the live wires, then connect it from there.

This diagram helps visualize what is going on in those switches:



The power feed can also come through the light or the switch on the end. You can probably figure this out by the number of wires in there, and if some are just wirenutted together. Speaking of that, make sure if they are, that they did not come lose.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9 Posts
Discussion Starter #13
3 ways... I always find them tricky to work with. Sometimes the screws on the switch won't correspond with the ones on the old switch.
Okay, so I am thinking out loud here. Could it have NOT been working because I only replaced the one side and not the other? Like the switch in the hallway, I changed, but I never made it to the other one in the living room because it wouldn't work and I didn't want to mess it up anymore? And then when I reinstalled the old one I just randomly picked up screws that I found from this crazy project and I really do not know if they were the right ones?! Yikes......... What is your insight on this?
 

·
You talking to me?
Joined
·
7,551 Posts
well, ever hear of Occam's razor?

the simplest explanation is usually the correct one.


Applying that to your situation: the lights worked before you changed the switch. They didn't work after you changed one of the switches. They still didn't work after you returned the original switch to duty.

simplest explanation is;

It's something you did.


so, if you didn't mess with the other switch in this circuit, don't start now.

with a 3 way switch, there are only 6 combinations of connecting the wires to it. any combination should cause the light to work is some combination of the two switches position. So, hook them up how you think they were. Turn the circuit back on and try the switch. Be sure to go to the second switch and try that one as well with the first switch in each of it's positions.

If it isn't connected correctly, you will not be able to turn the lights on and off from each switch like you should be able to. So, you turn off the circuit and swap 2 wires and try again.


the possible connections

wire colors
______________________________________________________
screw 1 black black white white red red

screw 2 red white black red white black

screw 3 white red red black black white.

there are 2 of those 6 connections that will work. The other 4 will result in the light not operating correctly by using both switches in various combinations.

without being able to check for voltage, that's about the best I can suggest.

well, that doesn't format well. maybe this will be more readable


(screw) 1, black (screw) 2, red (screw) 3, white

1, black 2, white 3, red
1, white 2, black 3, red
1, white 2, red 3, black
1, red 2, white 3, black
1, red 2 black 3 white

just number any screw 1, 2 or 3. It doesn't matter which is numbered which way. It is only a reference number.
 

·
Wire Chewer
Joined
·
3,579 Posts
Could possibly be. If one of the switches it not wired properly it can throw off the whole circuit, either make it act funny, or not work at all. There is always a "common" screw. Internally, the switch turns over power from that screw, to one of the other two screws. Usually the common is an odd color then the other two screws but I've seen situations where you just have to do guesswork.

What makes 3 ways hard is it's not always possible to actually identify what wire is what and where it goes but if you can do that, it makes it much easier. In most cases it is safe to just brute force until you get it going, if you're really stuck. Just be sure to identify the hot(black) and neutral (white) that come from the panel, so you do not cause a situation where they are put together. I had to do this in my hallway as it was hard to identify where each wire went.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9 Posts
Discussion Starter #16
Thanks everyone!

Nap, I will try those combinations tomorrow (when I have daylight again) and will let you guys know what happens! If anyone thinks of anything else at all, please let me know.

Thanks again!
 

·
You talking to me?
Joined
·
7,551 Posts
Just be sure to identify the hot(black) and neutral (white) that come from the panel, so you do not cause a situation where they are put together. I had to do this in my hallway as it was hard to identify where each wire went.
I am taking it on faith she remembers which 3 wires were on the terminal screws. At least I hope she does. If not, she will trip a breaker with some of those combinations.
 

·
You talking to me?
Joined
·
7,551 Posts
be sure to turn off the circuit breaker each time you change the connections.

Be sure to turn it back on when testing. (yes, been there, done that)
 

·
Retired Moderator
Joined
·
25,769 Posts
Just one thought---Get a tester and see if you have any power to the switch---

You may very well have cut the power to the switch when you snapped off all those tabs--

Just a thought---a cheap electrical tester is less than $3--
 
1 - 20 of 20 Posts
Top