[oh'mike]

Flat hides defects and wavy walls better than an egg shell--I am guessing that all three saw problems with your walls that would be exaggerated by an egg shell finish.

Did you ask them why they thought you needed flat?

Are you asking for a one coat job? Any gloss paint needs two coats.

---More info please.----

 

[Brushjockey]

As a pro I will advise on paint sheen, quality etc. But in the end, I will do as the HO wants. If my advice was clear, it usually goes that way, but not always.
It has been an eternal debate which is better , flat that touches up or eggshell that washes. Paint co's have made "washable flats" and mattes to be best of both, but mostly do neither well. Most painters have preferences too.

I would say the condition of the walls might be a tipping point, but they could possibly do a little mud work to make that better. If they know how...

 

[simiesue]

The painter I chose is having his drywall guy come out to fix all nail pop, corner bead issues and even a couple taping issues. So, in my mind, if I am paying $700 extra for a drywall repair, then why do I need to go with flat paint - that would better hide wall imperfections???? I do have a section where you see where the 2 drywall pieces meet and it looks like a line that somewhat bulges... I doubt they can fix this though.
I just dont know enough about painting to understand the consequences of going with flat or eggshell. I need to be able to wash the walls, especially with my young son. What happens if you wash flat walls???
UGH I need help!!

 

[Brushjockey]

Remember it's you hiring them. If they won't listen to what you want, get one that will. Sounds like you're clear- you want to wash, not touch up.
That would end the discussion for me. Make the client happy.

Do you know what ( company and product ) they plan on using? There is a world of differences in paints and qualities and what does what. Post that info if you know, and if you don't find out.
And a quality paint will cost a bit more, but it is still pretty minor to the labor so it is totally worth it to use good product.
My own clients who say what you have would get Ben Moore Regal Matte or egg, or better yet Aura Matte or egg.

 

[firehawkmph]

Sue,
I am pretty particular to sherwin williams paint. They make a low-sheen eggshell that is about halfway between flat and eggshell. It looks almost flat, but feels smooth to the touch and is washable. And it is also easily spot touched up. So you kind of have the best of both. I use their promar 200 line, which is the contractors line and one of their best paints they make. It applies easily, so I don't know why a pro painter would be opposed to it.
Mike Hawkins

 

[95025]

In the end - and after his advice is given - it's your house, and you're writing the checks. Either he does what you want done, or he takes a hike.

 

[simiesue]

Thanks for the responses. Initially, they said they use Sherwin Williams and Hershmanns(sp??). But when I told them I wanted to put the house on the market they recommended Behr Premium plus flat paint - I think because it is cheaper than the SW flat (so I really appreciated that!). But after talking with them, they mentioned that SW makes a washable flat????
Mike - that SW low sheen flat- is it more $$ than the flat?? If I go with this low sheen paint and wash it- will you be able to tell that it was washed (like show a lighter color??)
Thanks again for all your help:thumbup:

 

[Yggdrasil]

Just to let you know, Simiesue, SW is having a 30% off sale from June 9th through the 13th. There is also a 10$ off $50 coupon when you search for a local store.

 

[Bud Cline]

I actually had 3 different guys come out and all 3 said go with flat!

I just dont know enough about painting to understand the consequences

H-m-m-m-m-m!

These guys (here) are correct in that you are paying the costs, you should have what you think you want. BUT, Why ask advice from professionals then argue with the answers you get? Especially when the answers are unanimous and you are the only hold out. The property will be gone soon. Maybe!

Paint it "flat" to hide the obivious imperfections is my vote. Your child can't do anything you can't fix.

 

[ltd]

i mean you said 3 pro painters came out and all told you the same thing im going to say their right, and i would tell you the same thing .flat paint hides imperfections.theirs not a conspiracy here they are trying to help you.look if you want eggshell tell them to do it but they cant be responsible for what it looks like. you trying to sell your house make it beautiful and just keep you kids hands off the walls:huh:

 

[chrisn]

In the end - and after his advice is given - it's your house, and you're writing the checks. Either he does what you want done, or he takes a hike.

:yes::thumbsup:

 

[firehawkmph]

Simi,
Just to answer your other questions, yes the low sheen eggshell cost a few bucks more than the flat. And SW does make a washable flat. Costs more than the low sheen and it has to be cleaned with a spray product they sell. I have never used it for those reasons. SW's promar line is not cheap paint. I think the last time I bought the low sheen it was around $27 a gallon at contractor pricing. You can buy cheaper flat paints. Maybe that and a combination of hiding the defects is why the fellows were steering you in that direction. It's up to you.
Mike Hawkins

 

[simiesue]

Thanks again for the replys guys. I was just at Home Depot and I looked at the Behr plus line of paints. Looks like they carry a flat enamel that is washable and can be used in kitchens, hallways, etc... Has anyone tried this? Was it truly washable without you being able to tell that it was washed (paint color changes)? It is pretty inexpensive too... even cheaper than regular flat.
I know that pro painters get contractor rates at SW but do they also get good prices at say HD too?

 

[Brushjockey]

Spend a couple of mins looking through the threads about behr paint...

 

[user1007]

Just remember latex paints need 30 days to cure to a somewhat washable situation. This cure time is more critical the higher the sheen. With a lower quality paint like Behr and if you need to wash walls before 30 days are up? You could find yourself with a mess on your hands.

 

[Bud Cline]

How out-of-control is this child?

 

[simiesue]

My son is very young and doesnt 'get' that you should not touch everything... walls included. With the way the housing market is.... I could be sitting in this house come 2013.... so gotta be able to maintain the inside. lol
Has anyone used the SW washable flat or equivalent?? Also how much more is SW paints compared to Behr???
Off to go read the 'Behr' thread.....:wink:

 

[user1007]

If price difference for a few gallons of paint, and the fact you are hoping to sell the place are key factors? Step down to the contractor grades of SW, Benjamin Moore or other paint store paint and you will be closer to the price point of Behr. And you will still be getting much better paint. Watch for sales this time of year or ask for a discount.

If I were painting your project I would have no problems with you asking me to apply the contractor grade given your circumstances. I apply Behr only in bro bono situations and would not put it on your walls. Hopefully I could talk you out of it else I would not take the project.

The trade off between high end and contractor grades of paint store paint? Less acrylic and more vinyl in the paint film left behind and some differences in chemistry as well. Impact, ironically is that it may be less washable over time. Be sure to buy extra of the same color mix for touch up should you need it.

Some paint stores do sell another tier down of contractor grade that is mostly white and off white with the primary purpose of apartment turnaround.

By the way, if you have not discovered them, those Mr. Clean and Clorox magic eraser things are wonderful for cleaning up marks on walls.

 

[hammerheart14]

I sell pratt and lamberts paints at a local paint store, and I have done several washing tests on all kinds of flats, most of the time it doesn't work. But I found ONE flat that is not only washable but scrubable!! P&L's Accolade flat works damn good. Now, I am sure there are other lines that will wash too, like Ben Moore's Aura flat, but if you want something that WORKS, it gonna cost you a little more than the crap you can get at the box stores. BUT, some words of advice. ALWAYS buy your paint from a real paint store, because you will get better service, better advice, better paint matches, and the more competitive ones will be the same price or close as the box stores. TWO, remember, the cost of a bid is 90% prep work, and the paint usually only costs about 10% of the job. ALWAYS go with better paint, it will save you in the long run.