[creeper]

Tiling looks dated, even in granite. There are tons of nice laminate patterns to choose from. In my experience as a Realtor, as far as resale goes, if the kitchen is clean and the counter is in good shape, the laminate won't be a deal breaker,

 

[creeper]

The original post did say that resale was the most important factor. I've already stated what I think as a Realtor. I suggest some quick phone calls to Realtors in your area. Don't be surprised when/ if they tell you that tile is dated and todays laminate is fine.