Bathtub Drain -- Without Overflow Waste Trap

32997 Views 6 Replies 5 Participants Last post by Sharonmcelrath, Feb 15, 2010

sabinh

Discussion Starter · Apr 20, 2009 (Edited)

I'll introduce myself fully later, but I have a very quick question that could save me hours of work.

I've already used google to find solutions here on how to remove already set PVC pipes, installing a bathtub on a concrete floor, and tiling. I'm getting into the final stretch of a modest basement bathroom remodel and I've become a bit punchy.

I installed the rough in for the bathtub drain and set it in concrete (of course with a 12x12" box around the drain assembly. Last night I cemented the PVC together and had a perfect drain assembly that fit exactly below my new pop and stop tub drain! Exactly below. As I began to take out the drain from the box, imagine my surprise that the drain/overflow assembly is actually L shaped, not straight down, and my perfectly measured drain is now seven inches away from where it should be.

I DO NOT want to saw everything off again. For one, I have a very short tolerance for error as the drain only sticks out about 4 inches below the surface.

So my question is--are there any bathtub drain assemblies that are only a drain straight down without the waste overflow? SO instead of being shaped like an "L", it would be "I" shaped.

Thanks in advance,

sabinh

See less See more

Save

1 - 7 of 7 Posts

smorley

· #2 · Apr 21, 2009

An "L" or an "I" does not sound good to me a "J" Is good there has to be a place to trap water to block sewage smell.

Save

LookoutRanch

· #3 · Apr 21, 2009

sabinh said:
I'll introduce myself fully later, but I have a very quick question that could save me hours of work.

I've already used google to find solutions here on how to remove already set PVC pipes, installing a bathtub on a concrete floor, and tiling. I'm getting into the final stretch of a modest basement bathroom remodel and I've become a bit punchy.

I installed the rough in for the bathtub drain and set it in concrete (of course with a 12x12" box around the drain assembly. Last night I cemented the PVC together and had a perfect drain assembly that fit exactly below my new pop and stop tub drain! Exactly below. As I began to take out the drain from the box, imagine my surprise that the drain/overflow assembly is actually L shaped, not straight down, and my perfectly measured drain is now seven inches away from where it should be.

I DO NOT want to saw everything off again. For one, I have a very short tolerance for error as the drain only sticks out about 4 inches below the surface.

So my question is--are there any bathtub drain assemblies that are only a drain straight down without the waste overflow? SO instead of being shaped like an "L", it would be "I" shaped.

Thanks in advance,

sabinh

Let me see if I understand your situation:

The drain pipe is directly under the tub drain hole, rather than in front of the tub, under the overflow?

As long as there's a trap underneath someplace, you should be able to jury-rig a pipe set-up that directs the overflow to your drain. It's just a reverse of the usual situation, where the drain is directed to the overflow.

But is there enough room for the fittings? Can you reach it to work on it?

Is there a shower drain that would work? They're usually 2-inch, but if you could find a 1.5-inch, it might work if there's room.

Oy vey!

I'd be tempted to break up the slab in that area and reroute the drain pipe to the usual place. If you ever have to work on it in the future, you might be glad you did.

See less See more

Save

wrangler

· #4 · Apr 21, 2009

Hate it or not, just do it right! You're only asking for problems later. Like if you should ever have someone overflow the tub, get a clog, want to sell the house or an inspector catches it? It isn't that hard to correct. You saved alot of money doing the work yourself, but spend the few more
dollars to do it right or pay alot more later to have it re-done.
JMTCW
Brett

Save

sabinh

Discussion Starter · #5 · Apr 21, 2009

Thanks, guys. You are of course, right

Thanks all for the info. I've seen the error of my ways and will fix it so the drain is installed directly beneath the overflow and not the tub drain hole.

sabinh:thumbsup:

Save

wrangler

· #6 · Apr 21, 2009

By the way, sorry if I seemed to be sarcastic or dismissive, but often people come on here wanting justification for work already done, be it right or wrong. And while this is a DIY site, it is always in your best interest that advice is given.
Some of us have seen many horror stories, be it electrical, plumbing, structural etc., and offer our opinions and advice based on our own experience.
Brett

Save

Sharonmcelrath

· #7 · Feb 15, 2010

It is called a straight tub shoe

Hi, I am new at this site... I stumbled accross your message when searching for the same part. My tub also does not have an overflow drain. The part you are looking for is called a STRAIGHT TUB SHOE. Normally it is only a threaded fitting x hub (glued joint for abs) you can also get them in different finish types for tubs that have an old style appearance and the drain is exposed. They are commonly used with the old style footed tubs. If your tub does not have an over flow you do not want to use a drain kit for a tub that has one. You still do need to attach the plumbing to a P-trap. I purchase my fittings from Central Arizona Supply. Good luck.:thumbup:

sabinh said:
I'll introduce myself fully later, but I have a very quick question that could save me hours of work.

I've already used google to find solutions here on how to remove already set PVC pipes, installing a bathtub on a concrete floor, and tiling. I'm getting into the final stretch of a modest basement bathroom remodel and I've become a bit punchy.

I installed the rough in for the bathtub drain and set it in concrete (of course with a 12x12" box around the drain assembly. Last night I cemented the PVC together and had a perfect drain assembly that fit exactly below my new pop and stop tub drain! Exactly below. As I began to take out the drain from the box, imagine my surprise that the drain/overflow assembly is actually L shaped, not straight down, and my perfectly measured drain is now seven inches away from where it should be.

I DO NOT want to saw everything off again. For one, I have a very short tolerance for error as the drain only sticks out about 4 inches below the surface.

So my question is--are there any bathtub drain assemblies that are only a drain straight down without the waste overflow? SO instead of being shaped like an "L", it would be "I" shaped.

Thanks in advance,

sabinh

Save

1 - 7 of 7 Posts

This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.

Top Contributors this Month