stripedbass

Two days ago I had a new water heater installed. It's an AO Smith.

However, I'm only getting hot water for a minute or so and then the water turns cold. Then after an hour and I turn on the hot water tap, the same thing happens. The hot water comes on then it turns cold after a minute.

The plumber cannot figure out what's wrong.

Below are some photos.

Attached Thumbnails

   

LawnGuyLandSparky

Smart money is bad dip tube.

stripedbass

LawnGuy,

We have confirmed that the hot and cold are not reversed on the water heater.

We have also run the hot water till it turned cold then went to the basement and touched the hot pipe to see whether it was hot or cold. The pipe was hot. If the pipe was cold this supposedly means that the heater's dip stick is broken which would cause the problem I'm having.

stripedbass

My previous water heater was really old. It was installed around 1967. This thing was amazing. The only reason I replaced it is that its shutoff began leaking and it looked too fragile to fix.

I'm attaching some photos.

Attached Thumbnails

   

AllanJ

Does this happen at any faucet? Something else to try if you have not fixed the problem yet. Run a test rather than a full shower. When the water turns cold, run down to the basement and feel the hot outlet pipe of the heater. This latter could rule out an antiscald assembly up in a shower valve (or sold separately) malfunctioning and mixing in too much cold water.

Also the washing machine hookup should be turned off at the wall when not in use, which will prevent short circuiting of hot and cold water and also all sinks and other showers should be turned off using their regular faucets and not a sprayer hose shutoff.

(OT)
Allcraft? 1967? The apartment I grew up in (in the 1950's in Cambridge, MA) had an Allcraft with a copper tank (which replaced what I think was an INCO nickel tank). Such a tank will last a very long time.

__________________
.

jmon

Although rare, sometimes you can get one dead on arrival for some reason. It's a brand new install, if it doesn't work properly, the plumber should replace it with another one. Just my opinion.

stripedbass

Unlike the past 3 days, today I did not get hot water for even a minute. The water is just cold.

stripedbass

Hi Allan,

I had already tried this test. The hot pipe was hot when the water turned cold (someone had suggested the test to me). But thanks for trying to help me!

MTN REMODEL LLC

Obviously , you do not have any hot recirculating system involved.... or I'm sure you would have mentioned that.

Does this happen at other faucets through out the home.????

Maybe a strange coincidence with a bad shower anti-scald... I don't really know how they work... but perhaps the new water heater is set to deliver a higher temp than the old, and when it hits your anti-scald shower valve, that shower valve is acting strangly.

__________________
Never stop learning (xcep fer speling en typeing)

Bud9051

Maybe I missed it, but Allan asked "Does this happen at any faucet?" Is this just a problem at the shower?

If it is happening at all faucets then (as suggested) look for an anti scald device that can mix cold water into the hot.

I assume no other plumbing changes were made when water heater was installed?

Bud

__________________
I volunteer my help and opinions, but you are responsible for what YOU choose to do with that information.

Ghostmaker

Do you have single handle moen faucets? A bad O ring on the cartrige will allow pulling cold water into the hot water.

stripedbass

Hi Allan,

To your other points:

1) Yes, the problem with not getting steady hot water happens with all my faucets. I only have 2 faucets at the moment (kitchen and shower). My bath sink is disconnected at the moment (I need to install a new undermount sink bowl). I'm attaching photos of my faucets in case they are a factor.

2) My washing machine is always turned off when I'm not using it. And it does not have a switch on the wall. The only power switch is on the washing machine itself.

3) Yes, those Allcrafts are real beauties.

I'm in a 12-unit condo building. When I bought my condo in 2004, the home inspector told me that my Allcraft could last a week or another 10 years. The only reason I replaced it is because its shutoff was leaking and it seemed too fragile to fix. Now I'm kind of regretting it. We could have just turned the building's main shutoff off and replaced the water heater's shutoff. On well...

Attached Thumbnails

   

stripedbass

Today I'm getting hot water which seems to last a bit longer before it runs out the cold comes in.

The plumber has not been able to swing by place. Says he's really busy but will try his best.

stripedbass

jmon,

We'll see what happens. I hope the plumber, if he cannot fix the problem, will do the right thing.

stripedbass

MTN,

I don't think I have a hot recirculating system. I hope my faucet photos give you an idea of what I have.