Originally Posted by Michael Thomas
No way to tell based on the the supplied photos how much of the original flashing is still in place under the new counter flashing, or how well it was performed. Not saying it was done improperly, just that it's not possible to determine one way or another without pictures of the entire perimeter of the chimney after all the flashing repairs and before the counter flashings were installed and the tiles had been replaced.
It's starting to get a little wet on the roof these days so I probably won't be climbing up there until spring time. Thanks for your reply and response.