DIY Chatroom Home Improvement Forum

DIY Chatroom Home Improvement Forum (http://www.diychatroom.com/)
-   Roofing/Siding (http://www.diychatroom.com/f9/)
-   -   Roofing estimates (http://www.diychatroom.com/f9/roofing-estimates-102846/)

Dr.Fugazi 04-26-2011 10:28 PM

Roofing estimates
 
Hello all. Looking for opinions......

I'm currently in the market for a new roof. I've recieved a number of estimates and have narrowed my search down to 2. Both are comprable in alot of areas(tear off procedure, clean up, etc.)and both are very highly recommended. But there a couple things that are different otherwise, and was curious if anyone could give me some input.

Roofer 1 - Uses 30yr. Timberline shingles, double flashes the chimney with bothwaterproof barrier and aluminum, will seal the chimney with a masonry sealer, applies 3 feet of ice shield from the eaves, along with a 15yr. workmanship guarantee. $7800

Roofer 2 - Uses Timberline Lifetime shinges, flashes the chimney but will not flash with aluminum or seal with mansonry sealant, applies 6 feet of ice shield, along with 10 yr. workmanship guarantee. $7500

I'm looking for the better deal. Is the extra 5 years guarantee and work on the chimney better than taking the 3 extra feet of ice shield and Lifetime guarantee on shingles? Or vice versa?

I live in the Northeast and have a colonial with a decent pitch to the oof. Wasn't sure if this makes a difference considering the snow we've had and probably will continue to get.

Thanks.

Slyfox 04-27-2011 06:27 AM

GAF did away with the 30 yr Timberline and made gave them a Life Time ltd; Warranty, so their both selling you the same shingle, roofer 1 just hasn't changed the wording on his/her paper work yet.

Six feet of ice shield is twice as good as three feet.

I charge extra to re-counter flash chimneys.
I charge extra to do any masonry work.
I assume that's why roofer 1 is a few hundred higher then roofer 2, so if you like roofer 2 better, than ask him/her what they would charge for the new aluminum counter flashing and masonry sealing.

seeyou 04-27-2011 07:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dr.Fugazi (Post 637333)
Hello all. Looking for opinions......

I'm currently in the market for a new roof. I've recieved a number of estimates and have narrowed my search down to 2. Both are comprable in alot of areas(tear off procedure, clean up, etc.)and both are very highly recommended. But there a couple things that are different otherwise, and was curious if anyone could give me some input.

Roofer 1 - Uses 30yr. Timberline shingles, double flashes the chimney with bothwaterproof barrier and aluminum, will seal the chimney with a masonry sealer, applies 3 feet of ice shield from the eaves, along with a 15yr. workmanship guarantee. $7800

Roofer 2 - Uses Timberline Lifetime shinges, flashes the chimney but will not flash with aluminum or seal with mansonry sealant, applies 6 feet of ice shield, along with 10 yr. workmanship guarantee. $7500

I'm looking for the better deal. Is the extra 5 years guarantee and work on the chimney better than taking the 3 extra feet of ice shield and Lifetime guarantee on shingles? Or vice versa?

I live in the Northeast and have a colonial with a decent pitch to the oof. Wasn't sure if this makes a difference considering the snow we've had and probably will continue to get.

Thanks.


The minimum I&WS recommendation is 3' past the exterior wall over the heated space. If you have a house with no soffit overhang, then the 3' of I&WS may be adequate. If you have any overhang, the second row is necessary. It comes in 3' wide rolls.

IMHO, the extra 5 years of workmanship warranty is gilding. If they didn't install something right, it'll more than likely show up in the 1st few years.

Does the chimney actually need sealing? If Contestant #2 doesn't flash with Aluminum, what does he use instead? I'm assuming some sort of re-flash rather than re-using the existing. As far as the "double flash", we do a temporary flash with I&WS or Vycor while the roof is in progress, but once the permanent flashing is installed, the temporary flashing should never see water.

Grumpy 04-27-2011 09:09 PM

Codes vary, I believe the national code is ice shield 24" past the interior side of the exterior wall. In other words if you have an 8" overhang 3' of ice shield is usually enough, but this also depends ont he pitch of the roof. In most cases 3' of ice shield is not enough. If your overhang/soffit is 1', then 3' of ice shield is likely not to code. Contact your local building department and ask. On the majority of our jobs we install 6' at the gutter lines while our competitors who don't understand the code install only 3'. I should also mention some villages around here have amendments to the national code requiring 36" past the exterior wall. In this case more is better, and ice shield is cheap insurance.

Code says nothing about valleys, but valleys are very very prone to ice back up, therefore we install 3' or more of ice shield in the valleys. We will also preflash all problem areas including the chimney with ice shield. This also includes valleys, pipes, skylights etc...

If someone is flashing the chimney but not using aluminum, what are they using? Copper, steel, rubber? Copper or steel or aluminum is fine, stay away from someone using a membrane flashing. As for sealing the masonry, I don't. If it's necessary sure, but 99% of chimneys might need a little spot pointing. Sounds more like marketing to me IMO. Nothing wrong with sealing the masonry, but if it's not necessary then why bother? This is truly something to be approached on a case by case basis.


I offer a 10 year workmanship guarantee on my shingle jobs. However this year I began marking a standard Certainteed 5 star Sure start upgraded warranty into my jobs for 25 years. The point I am trying to make is simple: Who is backing the guarantee, roofer or manufacturer? In either case a warranty won't keep the water out, an intent to do the job right in the first place matters most. Truth be told, any major defect will usually show within the frst few seasons, while minor short cuts, like re-using flashings, usually show up within 5-7 years. I am sure you have noticed that the average roofer warranty/guarantee is 5 years, at least in my area it is.

Some other things you should be concerned with is not only chimney flashings but ALL flashings. All flashings should be replaced in part of the shingle roof project. What about ventilation? All ventilation should be replaced and in most cases, I find ventilation needs to be improved. Improved ventilation may mean changing the vent type, or increasing the ammount of vents. Bathroom and kitchen vents also need to be added on most houses older than 40 years.

Some links you should read before you sign any contracts:

Shingle Roofing
Hire the Right Contractor


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:26 PM.


Copyright 2003-2014 Escalate Media LP. All Rights Reserved