GAF Timberland HighDefinition vs BP Mystique Weather-tite shingles?
 

HI,

I am living in Lansing, MI. I got 23 squares roof to reroof with two layers to tear off.

I got quotes on using GAF Timberland vs BP Mystique shingles. The quote difference is around ~$1000. The GAF one is more expensive.

Both are fair? which one is better?

Thanks,

Guangming