What's your preference? Certainteed Landmark are very popular in our area, but the shadow and depth are too striking and repetitive for my taste (too much texture would overpower the look of our ranch house). I've heard the Tamko and Owens Corning have more variation in the pattern.
You will never get a "best" line listed since you are asking for a personal preference.
Look for something "YOU" prefer. No one knows your preferences better than you. Drive around to see something you like and ask the owner if he knows what he has. The next step is to look at samples and even drag them outside to see how they look in natural lighting.
The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to concretemasonry For This Useful Post: