DIY Chatroom Home Improvement Forum

DIY Chatroom Home Improvement Forum (http://www.diychatroom.com/)
-   Flooring (http://www.diychatroom.com/f5/)
-   -   Non Toxic quality hardwood floor stain (http://www.diychatroom.com/f5/non-toxic-quality-hardwood-floor-stain-160009/)

EHB 10-14-2012 10:07 AM

Non Toxic quality hardwood floor stain
 
I am new to this forum and NEED HELP. I apologize in advance if this topic has been spoken about (as I know how annoying it can be for newbies to do this), but I am quickly running out of time. My brazilian cherry hardwood floors are being put down as we speak and I need to make a decision quickly. If there is a thread about this, just point me in the right direction.

My husband and I just bought our first new home and figured if we are re-doing everything, we might as well try to make it as "healthy" as possible. But suddenly the idea of using a healthy stain on my new floors just occured to me... a week before a stain will go on. UGH.

Sooo, with that being said does anyone have any recommendations on a non toxic hardwood floor stain? I would like to balance QUALITY with healthy. We all know "all natural" deordorants don't work quite as well. :wink:

I would appreciate honest opinions. If you HATED non toxic, tell me. If you LOVED a certain brand, tell me.

Thanks so, so much.

gregzoll 10-14-2012 12:46 PM

Just have it stained, and leave the house for a couple of days until dried. Then open the windows and doors for a half a day, you will be fine.

You breathe in more harmful substances walking outside, driving, bike riding, getting your hair done, than 24 hours of doing your floors in your house

Ocelaris 10-16-2012 11:23 AM

I'm a skeptic of most superstitions about "Natural", I can understand eating things healthy, but floors need as hard of a surface as possible so they're not damaged and today's water based finishes are so safe you should not be worried. Just stay away from the oil based ones or anything that uses a solvent or isn't a 2 part catalyzed system. The cross linking catalyst in the 2 part systems is like epoxy 2 part systems, they make a chemical bond which freezes all the material in place so it never will rub or flake or evaporate etc...

Pretty much all 2 part (catalyzed) water borne finishes these days are what I would consider "green". But there are some (IMO) lesser performing finishes which are even more "green", but you will end up refinishing with any of these "natural" coatings within a few years. The 2 part water borne finishes already have low VOCs (volatile Organic Compounds). Once the finish is sealed, it's just that, sealed, nothing is coming out of it, you're not going to get cancer from walking on a sealed floor. You'd be better off wearing only natural leather shoes if you're worried about a floor.

The old fear was the off gas (solvent based, 1 part, or oil based) evaporating from oil based finishes. Today most finishes have a chemical (catalyst) which doesn't rely on evaporation for the curing. Once this process is done (a day at most), it's purpose is to be as solid (not gaseous) as possible, hence you're not going to get anything out of that finish.

Bona and Basic are two good brands. I used a Basic Coatings finish on my floor I did 5 years ago and it's held up great. Bona Kemi is probably the most famous brand, but a bit more expensive. Bona makes a bunch of more natural finishes, you should check them out, particularly "Natural"

Basic Coatings:
http://www.basiccoatings.com/Pages/default.aspx

Bona Kemi
http://www.bona.com/en-US/

Then you have all the "organic" type finishes, which are mostly a hard wax and oil, and don't really hold up, they're expected to be redone relatively regularly (every few years).

Rubio Monocoat is a very natural finish, I would never use it, but I'm a bit more skeptical about the "organic" / Green movement, so take that with a grain of salt.

http://www.monocoat.us/

Summary:
Today's waterborne 2 part catalyzed finishes are about as green friendly as you get, the old oil based solvent based finishes are no longer used most of the time, and that is what you're probably heard bad rumors about.

If you're spending a good amount of money (which you are), get a solid 2 part water based catalyzed finish and you will be happy. I did it, and it smelled vaguely of amonia, but the smell lasted less than a day, and it's been hard as nails today. Hope this was helpful and not too snipey! Organic doesn't mean safer! There are plenty of natural things (radon, lead, mold etc...) that you should be more worried about than your floor finish.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:16 PM.