DIY Home Improvement Forum banner

orange flame from GE stove

16K views 30 replies 9 participants last post by  fireguy 
#1 · (Edited)
Five years after moving into my home I am having a periodic issue where the flames on all of my GE gas stove burners glow orange (or orange/blue mix) instead of mostly blue.

I had PSE&G come and look at it today and although it was only partially orange (it had been completely blue just yesterday and the weather had not changed much) the tech told me it was nothing to worry about.

Probably just "something burning up in the air" he told me. He instructed me to not run humidifiers for a couple of days. Well, my humidifiers are all on the second floor (in our bedrooms) and they are only run at night. Not to mention I've been running them nightly since December and I have a blue flame 97% of the time.

And advice would be appreciated. My main concern here is safety from CO2.

Here is a 30-second video of the flame when it's only partially orange:
 
#5 ·
If PSE&G didn't check the gas pressures they are worthless.
How do they do that? I want to contact PSE&G and speak to a manager but I need some information as to what can be tested and how it can be tested. They told me that PSE&G would come out and do a safety check for free. All the guy did was turn on the stove and tell me not to worry about it.
 
#7 ·
That's logical advice however it doesn't explain why Saturday I had an orange/blue flame (as shown in the video) in every burner, then Sunday it was an all blue flame in every burner, then Monday again orange/blue flame in every burner.

The PSE&G guy told me it wasn't my stove, but rather the "mysterious" air in my kitchen surrounding the stove.
 
#13 ·
Does this require detaching the stove cover? Is it worth investigating this if all five of my burners are performing exactly the same day in and day out? It's not like one burner is acting up...they either all act up or none of them act up (and the flame is blue as expected).
 
#17 ·
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iiP1KcPdQMo
take a look at this since you said something about a humidifier..
Yes, I have seen this and other videos like it already. Our humidifiers are all upstairs in our bedrooms. They are small and barely increase the humidity of the rooms they are in. If it really is the humidifiers I would have been experiencing problems ever since the humidifiers were turned nightly starting in December.
 
#19 ·
Orange flame means something is combusting in the air with the gas. Whether it be dust, humidity, or otherwise.

If the flame tips are yellow it only becomes an indicator of primary air starvation. Too much air and the flame lifts off the burner/hissing is much louder.

Lazy flame indicates air starvation as well. But that issue is usually down to other things not normally associated with open burners.

Any galvanized pipes used in the gas line?
 
#21 ·
If you are absolutely sure it is not an indoor atmosphere problem, then I would investigate as follows:

1. Ask the neighbors with gas appliances if they observe the same flame color

2. Observe the flame color in other gas appliances in the home, such as water heater, oven, furnace, etc.

3. If the above is negative, then I would suspect the gas regulator located at the stove. The membrane could be going bad and disintegrating, sloughing off impurities into the gas stream. Replacing the regulator now would be wise before a serious fault developed.
 
#23 ·
Another example of gas flames being affected by a humidifier, this one on the second floor. http://www.chrisinch.com/blog/articles/show/why-are-the-flames-on-my-range-yellow/

Molecules travel, as I'm sure you know. Kitchens are often smoky & humid. Try the humidifier near the stove. Seems easiest thing to do. Also, anything that draws air, draws air in the house.
If you have that much humidity in your home (ie >80%) then I can guarantee you will have greater problems than orange flame.....and it won't take long.
 
#27 · (Edited)
In a series of experiments, I recorded a series of short videos today, all of them less than 30 seconds long.

The first one was taken as soon as I woke up. The humidity in the kitchen was 51%. This was probably due to my humidifiers running upstairs all night. My wife accidentally set them to the high setting and the kids rooms were about 77% humidity in the morning. After turning them off it was actually foggy in their rooms for an hour or so.

Even though the bedroom doors were closed all night, some of this air must have traversed its way down the stairs into the kitchen because the humidity level right next to the stove was as previously mentioned 51% (higher than I expected for February in NJ).

The first video below shows the orange flame at 51%:



A few hours later when I came home for lunch, the humidity next to the stove had dropped to 45% but still I had an orange flame.

The second video shows the orange flame at 45%:



I then opened all of the kitchen windows and ran a small desk fan next to the stove for about 45 minutes. When I returned the humidity had dropped to 35% and a dramatic change was observed. The flame was mostly blue now with just a small amount of orange.

The third video shows mostly blue flame at 35%:



Obviously there seems to be some component of this issue related to the humidifiers I use ("Crane" brand, "Drop" model). I have demineralization cartridges in all three of them which may or may not affect the composition of the plume of mist. I doubt it is the actual humidity level in the kitchen because I have not noticed this in the warmer months when the humidity level can be 50% or greater (especially if the windows are open).

It seems probable that the composition of the humidified air (despite the distant proximity) is causing the orange flame on my stove. As a followup experiment, I will not run the humidifiers for the next few days and see if and when I finally end up with a completely blue flame.

Comments/suggestions are always appreciated...:glasses:
 
#28 · (Edited)
Great work! I suppose it could be increased air/oxygen, too, from the fan drawing in air from outside. Your house is probably more air-tight than mine.

One thing that struck me is that your humidity & outside temp was the same as mine in Calif. I looked up your approximate area from the PSG&E area. We don't usually use humidifiers. But then I guess when you have increased cold & drier air, you need them.

I'm not sure why but I could only watch the videos once each, then it was ads. ( Science lab geek, I guess :)
 
#30 ·
One would think that as air becomes more humid, it would become heavier and thus more dense.
This would then theorize that there would be more "air" in a given volume. However, the opposite is true. Diatomic Oxygen (O2)has an atomic weight of 32 units, Diatomic Nitrogen (N2) had an atomic weight of 28 units. These are the two most abundant elements in the air we breath or your stove burns. Water vapor, comprised of two elements, has an atomic weight of 18. Thus as it replaces the components of a given volume of air the weight decreases. (providing that the temperature remains the same.)
As the "air" absorbs water vapor, it also displaces the other elements and thus reducing the amount of available O2 to burn which in effect will richen the fuel mix (more gas, less air)and cause the orange tips you see on the flame. It is possible that the air fuel mixture can be adjusted so that more air can be brought into the burners by a knowledgeable service tech. When we tune gas furnaces with a flue gas analyzer we are essentially setting the air fuel mixture to the "ideal" mix.
 
#31 · (Edited)
I do some commercial gas cooking appliance repair and adjustments.

1. Looking at the front of the stove, can you see the air adjustment disc? There is one air adjustment disc for each burner. Look for fuzz or other build-up at the adjustment disc. Wipe off any dust bunnies, fuzz or other build-up, using a soft non-metallic brush or cloth. I usually use my finger. Don't use air pressure to clean the disc

2. You may have blockage in the burner. Remove the burner grates, one at a time and examine the burner holes. If there is any blockage, insert a round, wooden toothpick in each orifice. Don't use a drill bit, the bit can change the size or shape of the orifice. Replace the burner and turn on the gas control knob. That may fix the problem.

3. The "tech" did not seem to have any idea what to look for. Some suppliers stop at the meter, but he could have used his meter to check for gas pressure at the meter. Our local natural gas supplier does not like there techs to go past the meter doing pressure tests. But every one of the techs I have worked with will go inside and test pressure at the appliances. They also will take there gas detectors inside and test for leaks. Propane suppliers techs vary in their knowledge and skill.

Have you added any new gas appliances since you moved in? The gas pipe installation may be marginal as to the size of the piping.
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top