I would suggest you resurrect the old thread where we all discussed this in detail rather than start anew. Thanks.
Correction: That would be threadzzzz, pick the most helpful and promising one. That will give us all the options we debated before.
Why not paint it a few times? Upload the image to a virtual painting program like those available free from Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams. It will take you a few minutes to mask off shutters, doors and things. Then try as many colors/combinations as you want from all their collections before you decide.
Once you have decided you can always get a quart to try to make sure you like your choice.