DIY Chatroom Home Improvement Forum

DIY Chatroom Home Improvement Forum (http://www.diychatroom.com/)
-   Painting (http://www.diychatroom.com/f4/)
-   -   Opinions on deck stains (http://www.diychatroom.com/f4/opinions-deck-stains-154061/)

spaceman spif 08-17-2012 09:45 PM

Opinions on deck stains
 
I repaired my deck last year and it's now good and seasoned and ready to be stained. I'm going with a solid color.

I wanted to know other's opinions and experiences with different brands of stains, plus suggestions on prepping. I've read a few of them on here, but wanted to try to get a few more. I tried Behr and found it peeled some after a year (I stained an old part of the deck, so it wasn't wet when I applied it).

I should add that it would be nice to buy any brand I wanted, but I am on a limited budget, unfortunately. :(

user1007 08-18-2012 02:42 AM

I would not use a solid stain on a deck surface unless you absolutely have to do so to cover color variations or something. Solid stains, even those that say they can be used on horizontal walk-on surfaces are going to be higher maintenance and will not wear well.

Sikkens and Cabot are good semi-transparent and semi-solid stains. Rather a purist I like solvent based stains for semi-transparent stains but acrylics for those with more pigment like semi-solids and solids.

Do scan for other posts on this topic using the search engine or just scroll down a ways. This topic comes up at least once or twice per week!

chrisn 08-18-2012 04:22 AM

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by spaceman spif (Post 991290)
I repaired my deck last year and it's now good and seasoned and ready to be stained. I'm going with a solid color.

I wanted to know other's opinions and experiences with different brands of stains, plus suggestions on prepping. I've read a few of them on here, but wanted to try to get a few more. I tried Behr and found it peeled some after a year (I stained an old part of the deck, so it wasn't wet when I applied it).

I should add that it would be nice to buy any brand I wanted, but I am on a limited budget, unfortunately. :(


just say no to Behr

spaceman spif 08-18-2012 09:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sdsester (Post 991373)
I would not use a solid stain on a deck surface unless you absolutely have to do so to cover color variations or something. Solid stains, even those that say they can be used on horizontal walk-on surfaces are going to be higher maintenance and will not wear well.

Parts of the existing deck that I left intact had a solid stain, so I planned on going with a solid stain all around rather than trying to strip and clean what was already on there. I don't know how old the original deck is, and I was worried that if I stripped and cleaned old deck that it might not take a new stain quite the same as the newer sections, and it would end up looking uneven.

Quote:

Originally Posted by sdsester (Post 991373)
Sikkens and Cabot are good semi-transparent and semi-solid stains. Rather a purist I like solvent based stains for semi-transparent stains but acrylics for those with more pigment like semi-solids and solids.

Is there a difference in how solvent based stains last as compared to acrylics?

Quote:

Originally Posted by sdsester (Post 991373)
Do scan for other posts on this topic using the search engine or just scroll down a ways. This topic comes up at least once or twice per week!

I did, I was just trying to fish for a few more opinions, specifically on solids! Thanks! :thumbsup:

spaceman spif 08-18-2012 09:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chrisn (Post 991384)
just say no to Behr

It looks like you're getting ready to stain your motorcycle. :wink:

CaptRandy 08-18-2012 11:23 AM

Wolman's Durastain semi or solid

Expert Paint 08-18-2012 07:08 PM

Rymar xtreme weather

Expert Paint 08-19-2012 12:26 AM

chrisn: that product on the far left is actually incredible. its like the poor mans impervex

chrisn 08-19-2012 06:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Expert Paint (Post 991930)
chrisn: that product on the far left is actually incredible. its like the poor mans impervex


not when it took 4 coats over grey primer and still looked bad:no:

Expert Paint 08-19-2012 03:52 PM

i mean, you have a dark blue in a value line from sherwin-williams. . . tough to hide in anything except the top of the lines like aura or emerald or whatever. i use solo all the time when proclassic isnt in the budget. . .it is super durable

chrisn 08-19-2012 05:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Expert Paint (Post 992209)
i mean, you have a dark blue in a value line from sherwin-williams. . . tough to hide in anything except the top of the lines like aura or emerald or whatever. i use solo all the time when proclassic isnt in the budget. . .it is super durable

now,I misunderstood you, the SW worked fine.

bsmith717 08-23-2012 10:52 PM

I guess it depends on the finished product your looking for. If your wanting to protect your wood and make it look a lot better you could do like I did, which was this. My deck is cedar btw.

Got some Olympic deck cleaner (I think its just bleach, anyone who knows please LMK and its ~$7.50/gallon) and sprayed down the whole deck and scrubbed with a deck scrubber that had a hose attachment. This was lots of work but after I did it, about 80% of the original stain was gone and the underlying wood looked great! Then I stained with Olympic maximum ((~$33/gallon). Two coats (two days) later the deck looks great and im certain the wood will be safe for another few years!

You can still see the residual stain that was left behind but its not the gross (reddish) tint like before, its just a bit darker then the stain that was applied to bare wood.

chrisn 08-24-2012 04:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bsmith717 (Post 995125)
I guess it depends on the finished product your looking for. If your wanting to protect your wood and make it look a lot better you could do like I did, which was this. My deck is cedar btw.


Got some Olympic deck cleaner (I think its just bleach, anyone who knows please LMK and its ~$7.50/gallon) and sprayed down the whole deck and scrubbed with a deck scrubber that had a hose attachment. This was lots of work but after I did it, about 80% of the original stain was gone and the underlying wood looked great! Then I stained with Olympic maximum ((~$33/gallon). Two coats (two days) later the deck looks great and im certain the wood will be safe for another few years!
You can still see the residual stain that was left behind but its not the gross (reddish) tint like before, its just a bit darker then the stain that was applied to bare wood.

Do not bet a lot of $ on it:whistling2:

CaptRandy 08-24-2012 09:59 AM

Do not bet a lot of $ on it:whistling2: agree fully!!

bsmith717 08-27-2012 10:57 AM

Would that be a foolish wager just because that's the nature of the beast? Meaning that no deck stain/sealants last longer than a couple of years?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:09 AM.