DIY Chatroom Home Improvement Forum

DIY Chatroom Home Improvement Forum (http://www.diychatroom.com/)
-   Painting (http://www.diychatroom.com/f4/)
-   -   Exterior Painting Estimates...need advice! (http://www.diychatroom.com/f4/exterior-painting-estimates-need-advice-22701/)

navi_jen 06-23-2008 02:58 PM

Exterior Painting Estimates...need advice!
 
Hi,

We're painting our turn of the century home in New England. and have some questions about the estimates we've received.

Currently, house has
-Cedar Shake shingles, of which many will need to be replaced
-Dark brown oil stain (alligatoring badly) on house body
-Off white trim (peeling badly).

We've narrowed the field to 2 reputable companies, but their estimates are very different in approach. So, need best practices/thoughts on:

1-Given we have stained shingles, what's best practice for new coating, stain or paint? Pros/Cons to either approach?
2-Since at least a 3rd of the shingles need replaced (don't ask), should the primer be different on the new wood as opposed to the treated shingles?
3a-If we go the stain route, what type of primer & stain (oil, latex) is best practice?
3b-Also, we have a choice between Ben Moore & Cabot stain, any recommendations?
4a-For trim (and painting route), 1 contractor quotes with Ben Moor-Guard, the other with Aura. Is there a specific difference in quality (or is it just marketing hype)?
4b-If there is a difference, is it 'acceptable' to ask the other contractor to use other paint (Aura seems to take some skill in applying).

Thanks in advance...

slickshift 06-23-2008 09:01 PM

1-Given we have stained shingles, what's best practice for new coating, stain or paint? Pros/Cons to either approach?

Stain
(*short of other extenuating circumstance...it's possible yours is one)

2-Since at least a 3rd of the shingles need replaced (don't ask), should the primer be different on the new wood as opposed to the treated shingles?

That depends on what primer and coatings are being used
Usually primers aren't use for stains

3a-If we go the stain route, what type of primer & stain (oil, latex) is best practice?

Oils will last longer, but have slightly more of a chance of growing mold
As always, it's a trade off
Oils aren't mold farms
Latex won't fall off in 6 months

3b-Also, we have a choice between Ben Moore & Cabot stain, any recommendations?

Either/Or...it's a toss-up with those two

4a-For trim (and painting route), 1 contractor quotes with Ben Moor-Guard, the other with Aura. Is there a specific difference in quality (or is it just marketing hype)?
MoorGard is an excellent choice
Aura is better
Specifically it is more washable, burnish resistant, fade resistant, and of course it's more environmentally sound
I suspect it will also prove to be much longer lasting and more mold/mildew resistant...but if you check my location, you'll see I have a good testing grounds for that....I'll have to wait till next year to say for sure
(it's not been out for a year yet)

4b-If there is a difference, is it 'acceptable' to ask the other contractor to use other paint (Aura seems to take some skill in applying).

You can ask
Some don't care for changing their ways or trying something new
Honestly most contractors I know that have tried it have been very enthusiastic about it
(which is kind of surprising actually....mostly we are rats in a maze and we hate it when someone moves our cheese)


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:48 AM.


Copyright 2003-2014 Escalate Media LP. All Rights Reserved