DIY Home Improvement Forum banner

Used spackle instead of joint compound on a wallboard repair--help

17K views 4 replies 5 participants last post by  Gary in WA 
#1 · (Edited)
First post, new home owner. Had to repair a 1' x 2' chunk of wallboard in the bathroom. Asked a HD guy how to go about it. He sold me some spackle and some joint mesh tape. I cut the new piece of wallboard, placed a couple pieces of plywood for backing, taped the edges, spackled the edges, and used a sponge to smoothe it out. The result looks horrible. Lol. I fanned it out as much as possible, but it still looks chunky. Luckily the area is just behind our pedestal sink in the bathroom.

Anyway, I want the job done right. I asked my boss about it and he said he's never heard of someone using spackle as a joint compound. He's concerned about it cracking. Being the novice that I am I had no idea...I thought joint compound, mud, and spackle were all the same thing. I learned my lesson to do the research on my own and not trust the HD workers.

What are my options here?
 
#2 ·
spackle

I have done a lot of plaster repair and always used joint compound. One day I was out of it and had a small repair and thought I could just use some spackle that was laying around the basement. Wrong! I'm not sure who buys that stuff of why they do, but it is horrible for wall repair. It doesn't have the same consistency, give or spreadability. Go with joint compound.
 
#3 ·
Spackle is ok for filling tiny holes from picture hooks, nails, and so forth but is no good for anything much larger. I never use it because you really cannot surface it easily.

If it bothers you you should probably pull your patch apart and start over with either a little drywall mesh patch and mud. Tape can work but something a bit more rigid would be better.
 
#4 ·
Yup, you need joint compound. Once again, bad advice from someone in orange! :laughing:

Remember that mudding a patch is a good three coat process. You can't do it in one. Also, don't plan on doing butt joints like you are with a 4" or 6" putty knife. You need a 12" knife to do it correctly. The idea is to build it thicker over the joint and feather it out 16-24" from each seam.

Thin coats is the key. I'd get some paper tape too. Mesh is great for tapered seams but I hate it for butt seams. Bed the tape in a coat of mud, and then smooth it with a narrow knife...Don't press so hard you squeeze all the mud out from underneath it.
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top