DIY Chatroom Home Improvement Forum

DIY Chatroom Home Improvement Forum (http://www.diychatroom.com/)
-   Electrical (http://www.diychatroom.com/f18/)
-   -   Simple wireless or X10 light switch? (http://www.diychatroom.com/f18/simple-wireless-x10-light-switch-176482/)

philS 04-07-2013 09:59 AM

Simple wireless or X10 light switch?
 
Hi -- I'd like to install a switch in my garage that controls the outside lights. They're now controlled only by a switch at the front entrance door, which is about 40 ft away from the garage. Wood frame house -- two walls between the switch positions. Yes, I could run 12-3 through the attic and down to the new and old switches but it would take a lot of work - fighting blown-in insulation, fishing wires, repairing dry wall.

I've looked at X-10 and all kinds of remote switches on the web and everything I find seems like serious overkill. Is there a switch that simply turns another switch and off? It could be wireless (RF) or it could inject HF signal into the AC, though that I think requires that it inject into the right AC leg. Obviously, there's no line of sight between the positions.

Thanks in advance --

stickboy1375 04-07-2013 10:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by philS (Post 1154031)
Hi -- I'd like to install a switch in my garage that controls the outside lights. They're now controlled only by a switch at the front entrance door, which is about 40 ft away from the garage. Wood frame house -- two walls between the switch positions. Yes, I could run 12-3 through the attic and down to the new and old switches but it would take a lot of work - fighting blown-in insulation, fishing wires, repairing dry wall.

I've looked at X-10 and all kinds of remote switches on the web and everything I find seems like serious overkill. Is there a switch that simply turns another switch and off? It could be wireless (RF) or it could inject HF signal into the AC, though that I think requires that it inject into the right AC leg. Obviously, there's no line of sight between the positions.

Thanks in advance --

I sell these all day long.....

http://www.homedepot.com/p/t/2023260...a#.UWF8L798v0c

philS 04-07-2013 01:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stickboy1375 (Post 1154032)

OK, thanks. So, I spent about an hour reading Lutron documentation and am still confused. The companion switch can be located anywhere? Some of their lit says it has to be within 30 ft of main switch if there are intervening walls (as I said, there are 2, and distance is more like 40 ft). It also says switches are not designed for subfreezing temps. For the entrance-door switch that's ok but not for the garage. Will the companion switch in the garage be damaged if it experiences <32oF or just not function dependably?

I'd also like to be able to use compact fluorescent and have no interest in a dimmer function -- do they sell just a switch system?

Total load is ~400 W so that part seems fine.

(I did go to HD and talked with both of the electrical people who said they didn't sell anything like this. Odd, because I know both these folks pretty well and they've always given me good info, or else said simply "I don't know". )

stickboy1375 04-07-2013 02:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by philS (Post 1154195)
OK, thanks. So, I spent about an hour reading Lutron documentation and am still confused. The companion switch can be located anywhere? Some of their lit says it has to be within 30 ft of main switch if there are intervening walls (as I said, there are 2, and distance is more like 40 ft). It also says switches are not designed for subfreezing temps. For the entrance-door switch that's ok but not for the garage. Will the companion switch in the garage be damaged if it experiences <32oF or just not function dependably?

I'd also like to be able to use compact fluorescent and have no interest in a dimmer function -- do they sell just a switch system?

Total load is ~400 W so that part seems fine.

(I did go to HD and talked with both of the electrical people who said they didn't sell anything like this. Odd, because I know both these folks pretty well and they've always given me good info, or else said simply "I don't know". )

I've installed these devices pretty far away, they did spec out a recommended distance, but you'll be pretty impressed with them, also, they do make a non dimmable version of this switch. Order it online...


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:28 PM.


Copyright 2003-2014 Escalate Media LP. All Rights Reserved