DIY Chatroom Home Improvement Forum

DIY Chatroom Home Improvement Forum (http://www.diychatroom.com/)
-   HVAC (http://www.diychatroom.com/f17/)
-   -   Loud Metal Scratching Noise as furnace starts (http://www.diychatroom.com/f17/loud-metal-scratching-noise-furnace-starts-132511/)

Ron22 02-04-2012 11:02 AM

Loud Metal Scratching Noise as furnace starts
 
I have a Carrier gas furnace that is at least ten years old. On occssion, when it tries to kick on it makes a loud metalic scratching noise that sounds like a metal rake scratching wire screen. The sound lasts a second or so. I am not sure, but I think that the gas valve is having trouble opening. The gas valve was replaced a little over a year ago. Prior to being replaced the furnace was making the same noise.

I have noticed that when the noise is occuring the inducer motor starts and the pilot light kicks on (9most of the time). The pilot light dims and the burners won't start and then the inducer motor stops. This leads to a gas smell near and around the furnace.

Sometimes the pilot will have trouble starting. I may hear many ticks of the pilot trying to kick on and then I will hear the loud metalic scratching sound. The scratching may occur several times before the furnace finally fires up. Sometmes it won't start and I have to shut the furnace down for hours before firing it up again without a problem.

I originally thought that the inducer motor wasn't creating enough draft to fire up the furnace and that was causing the gas valve difficulty to open.

I am leaning toward thinking that my new gas valve is bad or clogged, or possibly the wrong part. It was installed by a local contractor, but anyone can make a mistake.

I am at a loss as to what the cause of the problem is. Any suggestions will be appreciated. Thanks, Ron

Houston204 02-04-2012 11:05 AM

The inducer blower wheel is rubbing metal.

Tator1076 02-04-2012 11:14 AM

Agree with Houston 204 draft motor need replaced. It will get worst if not replaced.

barryweston 02-05-2012 02:31 PM

Hello, I have a Clare Megasave (HEG80B) which is about 20-25 yrs old. This morning a sound started coming from the blower motor (Model Emerson K33HXCFE-964). It is a whirring or a metal scratching. Similar to the original posters sound. After that sound goes on for about 1 minute the pilot ignites and then after another minute to rest of furnace kicks in and the blower goes out.

Is there anything I can do aside from replacing or rebuilding this motor?

Thanks!

EDIT: Here is a link to the pictures of the part in question.

Any help is greatly appreciated.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/barryjcweston/

Ron22 02-05-2012 02:42 PM

Thanks for the responses. I ordered a new inducer motor assembly several weeks ago, thinking that it might be failing. I will install the new one and see if that takes care of the repair.

If that doesn't work I will look into the gas valve and the mother board. Both of them were replaced a little over a year ago.

About the only part that wasn't replaced a little over a year ago was the inducer motor. That was one of the reasons that I was focused on the inducer motor as the problem.

Thanks again, Ron

Plumber101 02-05-2012 03:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by barryweston (Post 845130)
hello, i have a clare megasave (heg80b) which is about 20-25 yrs old. This morning a sound started coming from the blower motor (model emerson k33hxcfe-964). It is a whirring or a metal scratching. Similar to the original posters sound. After that sound goes on for about 1 minute the pilot ignites and then after another minute to rest of furnace kicks in and the blower goes out.

Is there anything i can do aside from replacing or rebuilding this motor?

Thanks!

Edit: Here is a link to the pictures of the part in question.

Any help is greatly appreciated.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/barryjcweston/


yes start your own post and not hi-jack someone eleses thread

barryweston 02-05-2012 03:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Plumber101 (Post 845169)
yes start your own post and not hi-jack someone eleses thread

The post is relevant and the same issue the OP is having, not hijacking, asking if I am in the same situation as the OP.

Since I cannot PM you Plumber101.

New thread http://www.kezoki.com/r.php?ls=en&ur...starts-132511/

Tator1076 02-06-2012 08:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ron22 (Post 845143)
Thanks for the responses. I ordered a new inducer motor assembly several weeks ago, thinking that it might be failing. I will install the new one and see if that takes care of the repair.

If that doesn't work I will look into the gas valve and the mother board. Both of them were replaced a little over a year ago.

About the only part that wasn't replaced a little over a year ago was the inducer motor. That was one of the reasons that I was focused on the inducer motor as the problem.

Thanks again, Ron

Wow you going to swap out parts until it works but can save more money to get a hvac tech. out and fix it right the first time. Looks like you save more money that way.

Doc Holliday 02-06-2012 11:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by barryweston (Post 845130)
Hello, I have a Clare Megasave (HEG80B) which is about 20-25 yrs old. This morning a sound started coming from the blower motor (Model Emerson K33HXCFE-964). It is a whirring or a metal scratching. Similar to the original posters sound. After that sound goes on for about 1 minute the pilot ignites and then after another minute to rest of furnace kicks in and the blower goes out.

Is there anything I can do aside from replacing or rebuilding this motor?

Thanks!

EDIT: Here is a link to the pictures of the part in question.

Any help is greatly appreciated.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/barryjcweston/


Once a motor starts making noise that's pretty much it, it's done, toast. Get a new motor and be done with it.

how 02-06-2012 12:21 PM

The one exception to needing to change the ID assy are those inducer motors which are rubber mounted. As they age the rubber mountings sag and allow the vent cage to make contact with with the inside case of the ID assy. I have often simply remounted them back into their original position. If you can grab the ID motor and easily move it a 1/4 inch in all directions then you may have one of those rubber mounted assys.

Ron22 02-06-2012 03:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tator1076 (Post 845796)
Wow you going to swap out parts until it works but can save more money to get a hvac tech. out and fix it right the first time. Looks like you save more money that way.

Tator 1076,

I appreciate your advice, but I have had at least three differnet HVAC technicians look at my furnance. That's how all of the parts were replaced to begin with. About the only part they didn't replacein trying to repair my furnace was the Inducer Motor. Studying the way the furnace functioned (or better yet how it wasn't functioning), I fugured that the problem might be the Inducer Motor. I ordered a new Inducer Motoer and have had it on hand for several weeks now. I wanted to confirm with some of the experts here on DIY that I was headed down the right path before replacing it. Based on the responses that I have received I most likely will correct the problem by replacing the Inducer Motor.

Thanks again to all for your advice. Ron

Tator1076 02-06-2012 03:35 PM

:rockon:
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ron22 (Post 846096)
Tator 1076,

I appreciate your advice, but I have had at least three differnet HVAC technicians look at my furnance. That's how all of the parts were replaced to begin with. About the only part they didn't replacein trying to repair my furnace was the Inducer Motor. Studying the way the furnace functioned (or better yet how it wasn't functioning), I fugured that the problem might be the Inducer Motor. I ordered a new Inducer Motoer and have had it on hand for several weeks now. I wanted to confirm with some of the experts here on DIY that I was headed down the right path before replacing it. Based on the responses that I have received I most likely will correct the problem by replacing the Inducer Motor.

Thanks again to all for your advice. Ron



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:07 AM.