I am curious what everyone recommends for insulating skylight tunnel. Currently there is 2x4 frame and the builder is proposing R21 batt but not sure how it will stay in place. is it advisable to use small R 15 and perhaps put foam board around the exterior frame?
Really need pictures. If it is in the attic space, there is really nothing you can do, other than build a box around it and insulate said box. Then the top would still conduct temp diff.
Rigid foam is better to the extent that it is not subject to wind washing but a combination of both will work as would a properly installed batt with some sort of air barrier on it.
Thank you and my apologies for not making myself clearer. I am located in Chicago so I am not sure what R value is required for "knee wall" areas such as this. The skylight is located in unconditioned attic space. This isn't actual picture of our house but very close to what we have:
One issue I see is 2x4 construction with the tunnel. Seems like there won't be enough room for both rigid foam... As mentioned previously, I think my installer was going to just put R21 with some insulation just sticking out. What sort of air barrier would you guys recommend? Plywood sheathing, Tyvek?
Insulated between the studs with unfaced R13 batts (or better yet something like Roxul because it won't sluff or fall down over time.
Install rigid foam over the studs to thermally uncouple them from the attic (minimum layer or 1" for complete thermal break). I would shoot for 2" as they get hot that far up.
Make sure the foam is covered or code compliant to be exposed.
Thank you so much for the additional information! I will definitely push for as much of ADA as possible. A few questions:
1. I am still a bit confused about how much R value is really required under the code for tunnel or knee wall - is it R38 or R21 for zone 5 (Chicago)?
2. I would love to see R38 on the tunnel but just not sure how feasible that would be. I can ask them to add another layer of 2x6 frame to allow total of 10" to allow R38 sticking out 2".
3. I am most curious whether using thicker batt which sticks out is better than using thinner lower R value batt with some sheathing.
4. He is using Kraft backed batt - is this the same as asphalt-coated? or do I need to specifically request?
Sorry for so many questions and thanks for everyone's help!
It is a side wall, so the minimum insulation for walls is required (my point was the great heat loss in the shaft/hole in the ceiling-plane), with a vapor retarder. Code also accepts foam board exterior of the cavity insulation in which case the vapor retarder is omitted. The dew-point of the cavity changes because the foam board keeps the wall warmer.
Use the faced as you said (without the foam board), though a high density batt is much better at stopping convective loops within low density batt;
"R-13 HD at 1.0# density
R-19 at 0.55# density R-21 HD at 0.90# density
R-30 at 0.57# density
R-38 at 0.53# density
Without the f.b., at least add a housewrap to the shaft on the attic side, over the f.g.- like Tyvek or similar permeability to let the moisture out from any air gaps in the ADA or regular diffusion (minimal).
Thank you! Great info but I am still dazed by all of the info... If you don't mind can I confirm a few takeaways from this post?
1. If I decide to use foam board, do I not use unfaced batt of R13 for 2x4 wall?
2. R13 + R5 = R18 (foam board) < R21 ... I guess eliminating air movement is more important than just R value for this application? I just want to ensure no condensation along the shaft and to keep the cold/heat out as much as possible.
3. If I decide to go with coated Kraft paper batt (R21) which sticks out a bit, can I still wrap it with Tyvek? I feel as though I might be "squeezing" the insulation while wrapping/taping...
Thank you! Great info but I am still dazed by all of the info... If you don't mind can I confirm a few takeaways from this post?
1. If I decide to use foam board, do I not use unfaced batt of R13 for 2x4 wall?---- correct.
2. R13 + R5 = R18 (foam board) < R21 ... I guess eliminating air movement is more important than just R value for this application? ----- correct. I just want to ensure no condensation along the shaft and to keep the cold/heat out as much as possible.------the f.b. will warm the cavity condensation free.
3. If I decide to go with coated Kraft paper batt (R21) which sticks out a bit, can I still wrap it with Tyvek? I feel as though I might be "squeezing" the insulation while wrapping/taping...----- the minimal compressing, if you don't wrap it snug, will hardly lose more R-value than you are gaining by preventing wind-washing of the batts.
Gary
P.S. FYI to all members; when a poster asks a question/s with a "quote" present from a previous post, proper forum etiquette is to wait on the member quoted to answer first, then cover anything pertainent with your answer. This is the primary use of the "quote" button/box- to direct it back to the original poster. Good manners are important everywhere, even on forums, otherwise it comes off as rude.
If you are worried about condensation, foam board is the only way to go. It breaks up the thermal bridging of the studs and keeps them much closer to room temp and therefore away from dew point.
Skip the R21 batt idea and use the foam. Just check the codes for exposed foams and once you have one layer on it, I would just as soon double it up.
Put the foil facing to outside and realize that the foil facing is a class I vapor retarder so make sure the drywall is air tight and there are no leaks where moisture can get into that space.
Thank you! Yes, it definitely sounds like foam is way to go. Unfortunately, it looks like Thermax is a bit hard to find. I am curious if Tuff-R will work just as well but am curious if I need to provide some fire proofing....
Quick update. I have a good news and sort of bad news. Good news is builder agreed to increase framing to allow R21 (I am sure he will find a way to charge me for this) but the bad news is that insulation guy is saying I need vapor barrier on the warm side even with the foam board?! Is this accurate? I thought unfaced was recommended.
Hi Gary - thank you for the info. Are there any issues with using kraft faced with my setup but this time just going with 1" foam board... Sorry for so many questions!
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
DIY Home Improvement Forum
3.1M posts
319.6K members
Since 2003
A forum community dedicated to Do it yourself-ers and home improvement enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about tools, projects, builds, styles, scales, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! Helping You to Do It Yourself!