DIY Home Improvement Forum banner

Contractor says he doesn't need to tape inside corner of drywall joint

9K views 26 replies 13 participants last post by  ben's plumbing 
#1 ·
I am having a built in shelving put in and there is some new drywall the buts up to existing wall. Contractor has not taped the inside corners adjoining the existing wall and ceiling.

Everything I know about drywall and can find on the net says you should tape either paper of mesh all inside corners

Am I missing something
 

Attachments

See less See more
1
#6 ·
curtd said:
Interesting. I've always used paper in inside corners. Because that was the way i was taught. Now after seeing your pic, i'm beginning to question why is paper and mud needed when the seam is small...why won't stay flexible caulking work ???

I wonder the same thing. Why would caulk be such a bad thing for a tight inside corner?

I'm not a drywall guy outside of small repairs, just wondering.
 
#8 · (Edited)
Actually, it is not as strange and as hack as everyone is making it sound.

There was no sermon on the mount that requiresd every inside corner to be taped.

Assuming a tight corner to begin with, often a very acute inside angle is caulked.

In applications of new drywall going up against old and textured drywall, a good quality caulk can provide a much better appearance than attempting tapeing the old formerly finished drywall.... without loss of performance.

There is the old school that probably has not considered the quality of new caulks that have come along way since the old crap that used to dry out.

In fact, think about it, mud is subject to cracking and paper can even tear. Caulk can provide a greater degree of movement... and much easier to repair.

(Think about it, in tileing it is virtually an industry standard/requirement... admittedly paper tape is stronger than a grout joint... but similar principals apply)

I'm not advocating caulking every inside corner... most are not tight enough anyways.... but there is no prohibition, and you will find it is used by perfectly legit contractors given the correct circumstances.

Best

Peter

(PS: I can't really tell your circumstances there by the pic.)
 
#9 ·
It comes up often in re painting/remodeling that caulk is used to fix cracked out inside corners. And when re rocking walls to textured ceilings.

As long as your not pushing the caulk beyond its dimensional limitations (a lot of drywall corners would) I don't see why it wouldn't 'hold' as well as or better than joint compound.

It might be an aesthetic issue if caulking the corners left them rounded looking instead of a sharp 90 degree corner.
 
#12 ·
I always thought it was a fire code issue. Don't know if all caulks are fire rated now days. Any thoughts?
Rob.... Most are not..... but I don't know any fire rateing issues.... apart from normal garage... two story chases.... balloon framing , cove ceilings etc

I don't very often (very seldom) not tape... and I don't even remember if I ever did on a permitted instance.
 
#13 ·
Seems to me if there were any wall movement that tape could hide that. Without tape the plaster would crack. It could with tape also but there could be some movement that tape would hide.
Caulk, What does the adhere to. It adheres to the plaster board and would not hide much movement. The previous owner of my house used it extensively and I hate it. It discolors if not painted and when it comes time to fix the area it is in it is hard to remove.
 
#18 · (Edited)
if you look closely at his caulking job at ceiling ...it looks like @!#$@^ well you know what i mean...thats why i said taping and finishing looks excellent...:thumbsup:
OK... Take your word for it..... (I can't see that detail).... maybe the guy has to learn how to lay down a smoth bead....or maybe the painter didn't have two shots of Old Crow to steady his hand...

Ben.... There are many instances where tapeing and finishing looks like krap also.... so what.

(Ben...earlier, I was merely stateing that there are some circumstances where caulk is acceptable, maybe preferential, to use in an inside corner, and that many legitimate contractors will use that application... and achieve better performance.)

I know, so does everyone here know, you have 40 years experience... but it is also important for us old F's to keep our minds open.

Best

Peter
 
#26 ·
"For many years contract documents describing how
gypsum board walls and ceilings should look prior to final
decoration with paints and other wallcoverings have included
nonspecific terms such as “industry standards” and “workmanlike
finish.” And, for as many years, wall and ceiling
contractors have tried to fulfill their obligations by providing
the finish conditions envisioned but not truly described." From; http://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=...sg=AFQjCNHmRKffHZdxrGtBUkonlCTgUuLD6g&cad=rja

There is now a guide, not yet in the codes (same but better pics); http://nationalgypsum.com/resources/tech-talk-revisiting.htm

Gary
PS. Welcome to the forums!
 
#27 ·
"For many years contract documents describing how
gypsum board walls and ceilings should look prior to final
decoration with paints and other wallcoverings have included
nonspecific terms such as “industry standards” and “workmanlike
finish.” And, for as many years, wall and ceiling
contractors have tried to fulfill their obligations by providing
the finish conditions envisioned but not truly described." From; http://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=...sg=AFQjCNHmRKffHZdxrGtBUkonlCTgUuLD6g&cad=rja

There is now a guide, not yet in the codes (same but better pics); http://nationalgypsum.com/resources/tech-talk-revisiting.htm

Gary
PS. Welcome to the forums!
there it is ..gary make sure to take the test...in the post i started:thumbsup::thumbsup:
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top